Quote Originally Posted by General_Gronker View Post
Uh, if you set up a scenario like Running with the Devils and then punished the players for playing it, that would make you a bad DM. So your point doesn't really stand.
No, it doesn't.
You never DMed have you?

It would be very easy to setup a scenario in a PnP game that was similar to Running and it would not be wrong in any way to expect a Paladin to come up with a way around the problem of being attacked by good aligned NPCs. The linear progression that is necessary in a computer game was non-existent in the D&D games I played.

If you want to make alignment an integral part of your game but do not give your players any alignment based challenges, then you are a bad DM. And probably a boring one at that.