The Arguments for Character Respec

[Mhykke]

Good point lets look at that with a WOW comparision yes I said wow.

Many top raid guilds require your spec to be x y z and get away with it bcause they know you can walk up and poof there is x y z spec. This is already being done to some extent to casters in this game. I do not see the ability to full repec (which will allow the demand of an exact spec) to be for the enjoyment of the masses. I see it as a way to run around with a level one that already has full raid gear in the bank. The only people who really benifit are the few that have tons of raid gear or those that play so little they can't level another up. This is in no way the majority. And I personally don't want anything in place that will make the whole you must x y z become a full reality.

The fear of "you must be x y or z" could easily be handled if a respec was on a long timer, correct?

[FluffyCalico]

The fear of "you must be x y or z" could easily be handled if a respec was on a long timer, correct?

Nope lets say 1 month. Guild leader, I know you can respec in the next month so by day ... you must be x y z or your are out. It's not x y z for a quest. It's x y z to be in the guild period

[Mhykke]

Nope lets say 1 month. Guild leader, I know you can respec in the next month so by day ... you must be x y z or your are out.

You're just arguing degree. What about once every 12 months? Do you really expect someone to suggest to someone else to respec their character in a game that only allows 1 per year, for example?

[FluffyCalico]

You're just arguing degree. What about once every 12 months? Do you really expect someone to suggest to someone else to respec their character in a game that only allows 1 per year, for example?

Hm... not sure I have an objection to this other than I plain don't like repecs. I could look the other way if they did this. And yes this is very different than 1 per month

[Tanka]

Maybe you did not get the memo, 4.0 has PHB2 also.

http://dnd4.com/rumors

I have 3.0 in front of me, I think but no 3.5 PHB2. Is it about the energy drain from a wight?

Perhaps, before making unsubstantiated claims, you would do well to do a little research into points made by other parties before attempting to refute them.

[Mhykke]

Hm... not sure I have an objection to this other than I plain don't like repecs. I could look the other way if they did this. And yes this is very different that 1 per month

I'm open for there to be some kind of prevention of people respeccing constantly for the current flavor build (even though I don't consider this a big problem). I think there's some common ground where people would have the opportunity to adjust their character eventually according to a different game than the one when they created and leveled their character, at the same time not allowing for that person to simply completely readjust their character on a whim.

[FluffyCalico]

I'm open for there to be some kind of prevention of people respeccing constantly for the current flavor build (even though I don't consider this a big problem). I think there's some common ground where people would have the opportunity to adjust their character eventually according to a different game than the one when they created and leveled their character, at the same time not allowing for that person to simply completely readjust their character on a whim.

At least you are being reasonable and trying to make sence. Thanks for creating an actual discussion out of all the BS from others that shall not be named.