OfElectricMen asked about the location of your ingredients because, when used remotely for crafting, Shared Crafting Storage is known to destroy ingredients. Never, under any circumstance, craft remotely using ingredients in Shared Crafting Storage.
We need more information. Where, exactly, were your ingredients located at the time you attempted to make the cloak? In your character backpack? In an Ingredients Bag inside your character backpack? In shared crafting storage? Some in your backpack, some in shared crafting storage?