Mantle comparison chart Preview 2

[Synthetic]

Tier	Legendary Dreadnaught	Fury of the Wild	Divine Crusader
1	Terror Stacks(Debuff)	+15% helpless damage heal dot
2	+1 W w Action Boost active		DR Bypass Alignment BAB=level
3	+15 PRR + 1d6 dot per terror stack	6% fort bypass +15% helpless	Favored weapons +3 enhancement, implement, , +1W
4	+15% helpless damage		+10PRR 10% Acid/cold/Electric petrification immune
5	Regenerate action boosts		Shield is a favored weapon shield 50% doublestrike
	Grand Master of Flowers	Unyielding Sentinel	Shiradi Champion
1	Knockdown Immune other stuff		Proc - 3d100+200*(2*rp) 15% 3d100+200*sp 30%
2	+1W	15 HA 15% absorb and immune to mind control	damage proc(3d100+300 percen as above) + blind or slow
3	+15% helpless damage	d6 law/level aoe on hit CD 8s	rainbow proc
4		+15 AC +5% absorb	9% helpless damage DR 10 Cold Iron and +5 force and universal spell power.
5		20HA 10% insight bonus to HP 20% with mantle active	paralyze or freeze proc
	Shadowdancer	Dranonic Incarnation	Primal Avatar
1		Dmg proc 1d6+6/clvl 5s CD 25% proct chance
2	Ghost touch Sneak/movement speed		damage proc on spell cast
3	+3 sneak dice +3 spell pen	T1 dmg proc becomes x4 dmg dot	share mantle with summons
4	15% helpless damage	10% spell cd mobile spellcasting 30% move speed(enh)	Spell power + temp spell point proc
5	25% incorp float/hide/ms
	Magus of the Eclipse	Fatesinger	Exalted Angel
1	50% Cold absorb + 50 Neg or light absorb		Dmg Proc 25% 1d4+4 fire or light dependent on spell cast
2	2d4 cold+2d4 neg damage per lvl aura 6s tick	on dmg (attack or spell) d6/lvl dmg 6 temp hp/lvl 10s CD	Immune to natural poison/disease
3	share mantle with summons	Immune to ASF	1d4+1/lvl heal aura 6s tick * spell power
4	15% dispel on strike/cast -4 SR	Immune to cha damage1d2/lvl heal+restoration on song use	15% dmg absorb(except physcial/untyped) +10MRR
5	+10 Neg/Cold SP +20USP +20 MRR

[cru121]

I applaud your effort.
It would be nice if someone prepared a similar resource for epic strikes.

[SocratesBastardSon]

+1 for this very helpful overview.