Originally Posted by
Fwuffy_da_Destwoyah
create the game. But it doesn't matter, because if you're going to appeal to the Authority of Gygax, you're gonna have to start with the changes made to the base system, and the pnp editions behind that long before you get to PVP in the game.
Uh, no. That's not how violating the spirit of something works. This particular game, despite how many people may solo these days, was designed so that a group would get together and invade the homes of creatures, murder them, and take their stuff.
You need to stop assuming that we aren't familiar with what you're talking about. Some of us have actually stepped into the arenas a few times.
Citation needed.
This sounds like you're really not up on the sheer volume of pnp modules available, with a boat load of them being plenty good enough for adaption. Given the speed with which the dev team adapts one, they've got decades of solid adaptable material available.
As for the actual suggestion:
1. On one hand, no. Complete and utter waste of resources, akin to suggestions for setting up special servers that only allow what was in the game from the start to (insert favorite update here) or the specialized permadeath servers that have been suggested. In theory, resources should be spent on what applies to the largest segment of the fan base, and the simple truth is that the PVP crowd is, and will always be, insignificant in that consideration (mind you, I have no problem with those folks).
2. On the other hand, no. If people want to be able to kill the characters of other players, then honestly, that should be possible in any environment in which those characters can interact, removing the need for special areas.
3. On the third hand, anyone who wants to ban or remove effects from PVP isn't really interested in PVP, they're interested in showing off their characters. If you've got a true PVP environment, then everything should be on the table.
4. On the other, other hand, let's do it!! Not because I support the idea, but because I admit that one of the secret pleasures I get from this game is seeing how badly things get screwed up with updates, patches, and new additions. It's like "How on Earth did you break this while tinkering with that?" and I can only imagine that revamping the PVP would be akin to watching a complete server merge happen in terms of all kinds of random things breaking.