Haven't seen a thread on this topic in over a year... in fact IIRC all discussions about this were included in more pressing concerns (like Renown Decay).
So here goes. Kindly stay positive.
Guild Management System
Needs to be comprehensive tool, something that helps guilds from birth through death; from the player seeking to join, to joining, to being a good guildmate, to leaving the guild; to competing against other guilds.
Currently we have only a partially completed, fragmented system. Currently there is no in game way to look for a guild; no way for a guild to advert for more recruits; no way to easily or effectively track and manage a guild. This has to change in order for the game to survive and thrive.
Having a GMS would promote the health of the game because it would make finding, joining, and running a guild manageable, far less stressful and all achievable / done in game.
We cannot expect a GMS to be added overnight, rather would expect it first half of '16, which allows the Dev team to get through all the fun juicy bits they already have planned. (Say after the Cannith Crafting Pass) (So around U30 or U31) but before DDO's 10th Anniversary.
Why before the 10th Anniversary? Because that event will generate so much self-marketing that there will be a big surge of new and returning players. In order to KEEP them playing - they need to easily and readily find guilds that match their expectations.
WIIFM (So how does Turbine benefit)?? Guilds spend real money. Cost for a fully tricked out Kraken? 10,000 Astral Shards+++. Guilds help to keep players happy and Guilds tutor, mentor. and promote play. More play means more real money goes to Turbine.
Players Council Members - current and former : kindly lobby for this.
In order for a GMS to be considered successful the following needs have to be met:
- Adverting / Recruitment / Researching / Pledging
- Guild Life
- News
- activity log, it registers the guild events (creation, join, promotion, leveling, reincarnation etc)
- log of the guild vault (Guild AD / Plat bank events - guild chest adds/removes)
- Calendar
- Anniversaries
- Special Events
- Guild Mail
- Forums (pipe dream – but at least allow a space to list url)
- Guild Management
- Roster
- Permissions
- Ranks
- Information
- MotD (Message of the Day) (more than the 128 or 256 characters now)
- Statistics