Originally Posted by
Faltout
So much this.
My mechanic recently picked up assassinate (at level 17), because mechanic tree had nothing else to offer and assassinate was just there. I have a good INT, deceptions, bluffs and shadow dagger.
So yesterday I was playing with a full group the LoD chain. While in a group, performing sneak attacks is easier, so I didn't have to worry about deceptions/bluffs/blindness but since assassinate can kill 1 maybe 2 monsters per 1 or 2 encounters, I had to choose wisely. Of course by the time I made my choice (it takes about 2 seconds to spot a target), the party had already taken damage and all monsters would have about half health. So I mostly went for the champions and the monsters in front of me that had more than half health. Imagine my frustration when the champions showed a deathward icon on top when I tried to assassinate (I didn't have the time to also check champion buffs) or a random drow show the deathward icon because a priestess was nearby. After a failed assassinate, I would switch to my repeater and start getting away from the fight to mitigate damage. I would maybe hit one monster with sneak attacks and then the fight was over.
So, to recap, it took me about 2 seconds to spot a target for assassinate, then about 2 seconds to get close to it, then about 1 second to make sure sneak is activated, then 2 seconds to realize assassinate failed, then 1 second to switch to repeater and then about 2 seconds of DPS against a monster. That's 10 seconds of minimal contribution to the fight. And the fight only lasts about 10 seconds.
Then there was another moment with a Hezrou in Spinner. I was determined to assassinate him. So I use assassinate, but it wasn't a sneak attack. Ok, run around for the cooldown. Then use shadow dagger to blind, wait for him to perform one attack so he won't hit me, get close to him, activate sneak... hit assassinate... oh, sneak never activated... activate sneak... activate assassinate... bah, no longer blind... run around for cooldown... use shadow dagger... avoid one attack... get close to him... I'm dead. I was so focused on getting the assassinate to work that I hadn't noticed that my health was so low because I allowed him to hit me with oh so many attacks while getting sneaky and close to him.
The funny thing is I would have easily killed him if I used my repeater. With bluff, shadow dagger and deception on item and on repeater, my DPS was high enough. And I would have stayed out of range.
I don't know what is wrong with assassinate... Is it me? Am I taking too long to make decisions of who to kill and where to move? Is it the switch to sneaking that is taking too long? Is it the blindness that allows them to hit me breaking sneak?
Maybe dropping the sneak requirement for assassinate is best. Keep sneak attack requirement, but drop sneak. (Still make it so it doesn't break sneak) That would allow an assassin to perform extremely well in parties assassinating every time it's on cooldown.
On another note, don't release items with a boost to assassinate bigger than what the tree can provide. And move that speed while sneaking to the assassin tree for god's sake. It's an assassin that needs speed.