I am VIP and have paid similar to this as well, not as many years however, maybe 3 now?
***edit*** not $2000! I meant a similar rate per year and expansions etc.
The solution is easy, whenever they give VIP a perk it should be for sale in the store to the premiums. So this weekend you should be able to buy the VIP exp perk for 250TP. Then the game is working exactly as intended.
(you know that is not what they want though. They want to spend less by their math and brag in forums about what geniuses they are and tell everyone VIP is stupid, do it my smart way. THEN want to come trash on turbine anytime they try to make VIP NOT look stupid.)
I think this would be beautiful solution. lol
You should also be able buy the run fast around town (lol) for 995 turbine points, per server mind you.