In the interest of being thorough, I tried logging in with the VIP subscription. World closed.
Closed launcher, tried logging in with the other subscription. World closed.
Closed launcher again, tried VIP subscription again. World closed.
Not to change topics, but is there some way to remove the extra subscription? I don't use it and I'm pretty sure it only exists because I messed something up while trying to get into Lamannia for the MotU beta.