Epic Gianthold...

[THAC0]

So... With Update 17 and the rumored upgrade to Epic GH quests..... What are the chances Devs that Vale quests / Shroud will get an Epic boost? I'd love to upgrade my greensteel weapons to epic levels...

Juat ask'n.

T.

[Maxallu]

Really psyched for pic GH, please make this happen devs.


Epic bluescale, I want!

[Ginarrbrik]

Really psyched for pic GH, please make this happen devs.


Epic bluescale, I want!

It's definitely gonna happen. FoS confirmed both. And I'm also quite excited.

Epic shroud on the other hand... it would be cool, but I really doubt it'll happen.

[JOTMON]

I forsee a Power Ranger party.
Epic Red Dragon Armor
Epic Green Dragon Armor
Epic White Dragon armor
Epic Black Dragon Armor
Epic Blue Dragon Armor.

Still missing the Epic Pink Dragon Armor... hmm maybe a Dragon armor dye kit .....

[Zzevel]

I forsee a Power Ranger party.
Epic Red Dragon Armor
Epic Green Dragon Armor
Epic White Dragon Armor
Epic Black Dragon Armor
Epic Blue Dragon Armor.

Still missing the Epic Pink Dragon Armor... hmm maybe a Dragon armor dye kit .....

And if you get one of each in your party they can summon Captian Planet or form voltron...

[Krelar]

And if you get one of each in your party they can summon Captian Planet or form voltron...

Now I want items that grant set bonuses if the entire party is wearing the correct parts...

[TrinityTurtle]

While I woudl love epic shroud, I think making green steel any more complicated would be a mess to figure out wht to do with it. Maybe add a fourth epic tier?

[Krelar]

While I woudl love epic shroud, I think making green steel any more complicated would be a mess to figure out wht to do with it. Maybe add a fourth epic tier?

It already exists!

I got a item from the best dev ever, kabold, and this item is unique.

It is an epic item, but also a shroud item!
Oh and he also leveled me to 20!

(Note this post is from lamannia over a year ago and a dev later says this item is just a test and never meant to see the light of day)

[Memnir]

Epic versions of the Vale quests? Sure - sign me up!

Epic Shroud and Epic Greensteel? No thank you.


Greensteel has ruled the roost as far as gear is concerned until just recently. It's still very significant gear for many many levels. It's been this way for four years. I'm sick and tired of Greensteel - and would hate to go back to that being the end-all-be-all. It had it's day, and thankfully the sun seems to be finally setting on that day.

[voodoogroves]

Epic versions of the Vale quests? Sure - sign me up!

Epic Shroud and Epic Greensteel? No thank you.


Greensteel has ruled the roost as far as gear is concerned until just recently. It's still very significant gear for many many levels. It's been this way for four years. I'm sick and tired of Greensteel - and would hate to go back to that being the end-all-be-all. It had it's day, and thankfully the sun seems to be finally setting on that day.

It still having its day. Very little replaces the HP and SP items, and many folks are TRing now, so GS equipment remains incredibly useful. The fact it's still useful into epic levels is crazy good - I'm just glad it isn't the universal answer.

[Miow]

Epic versions of the Vale quests? Sure - sign me up!

Epic Shroud and Epic Greensteel? No thank you.


Greensteel has ruled the roost as far as gear is concerned until just recently. It's still very significant gear for many many levels. It's been this way for four years. I'm sick and tired of Greensteel - and would hate to go back to that being the end-all-be-all. It had it's day, and thankfully the sun seems to be finally setting on that day.

The greensteel loot system is the best system they ever invented.

[Memnir]

The greensteel loot system is the best system they ever invented.

I agree, but they painted themselves into a corner in doing so. A bad corner - and one that has frankly stymied nearly all other loot relevance and growth since it's inception. Greensteel has been around for nearly five years now, the majority of this game's life-span - and it's a sad sign of overall game growth and development that it's still king after this much time. They made it too good for it's time - so good they've been afraid to do anything significant since.


I'm bored with Greensteel, and have been for a long time. I'd be happy if we just moved on, or at least didn't fall back on the GS crutch for future loot. I'd frankly rather see the game evolve then reheat the leftovers of the past. And I'd love to see the Devs have the balls to make something that'd shake up loot a bit more then they have.

[Cyr]

I agree, but they painted themselves into a corner in doing so. A bad corner - and one that has frankly stymied nearly all other loot relevance and growth since it's inception. Greensteel has been around for nearly five years now, the majority of this game's life-span - and it's a sad sign of overall game growth and development that it's still king after this much time. They made it too good for it's time - so good they've been afraid to do anything significant since.


I'm bored with Greensteel, and have been for a long time. I'd be happy if we just moved on, or at least didn't fall back on the GS crutch for future loot. I'd frankly rather see the game evolve then reheat the leftovers of the past. And I'd love to see the Devs have the balls to make something that'd shake up loot a bit more then they have.

Sorry Mem, but the only thing killing future loot advancement is Turbine. It's not the eSoS, it's not GS, and it's not the torc.

It is a lack of creativity and the lack of paying attention to good advice given about loot design for years.

Shade had this right all along. You want valuable loot you make more powerful loot in certain situations not more powerful loot all around. You just run out of desirable items really fast if everything is a best in slot thing or everything is just a mishmash of abilities.

[SealedInSong]

Sorry Mem, but the only thing killing future loot advancement is Turbine. It's not the eSoS, it's not GS, and it's not the torc.

Everyone was thrilled to have Genasi update items because, even if he didn't quite make the sweeping advancements that one may envision, he did listen to the player base. He crafted items that were desirable for a particular function that appealed to many builds that did not trump other items.

He followed the crowd-sourced, best-informed information possible: that of the players.

Any sensible player knows that we don't need a greensteel upgrade. It more than fulfills its function--it actually monopolizes gear for almost half the game, which is a terrible thing. If anything, we need more customizable loot just below greensteel (lvl 7-11) and just above greensteel, around where dragontouched armor is (lvl 16+) that isn't tier1 alchemical (only customizable as far as its base item, metal, and one tier of effects).

Also, if anyone advocates MORE SHROUD GRINDING, I send you a complimentary punch in the face. Go play WoW.

[Memnir]

Sorry Mem,

Yeah, I know it. I've just kinda hit the saturation point on the whole thing, ya know?

[RobbinB]

Sorry Mem, but the only thing killing future loot advancement is Turbine. It's not the eSoS, it's not GS, and it's not the torc.

It is a lack of creativity and the lack of paying attention to good advice given about loot design for years.

Shade had this right all along. You want valuable loot you make more powerful loot in certain situations not more powerful loot all around. You just run out of desirable items really fast if everything is a best in slot thing or everything is just a mishmash of abilities.

While the statement that follows is very true, you really don't need to give Shade the credit. Might as well give him credit for batman builds or the sun rising. Some things are just obvious (at least to anyone that doesn't work for Turbine).

[sirgog]

I agree, but they painted themselves into a corner in doing so. A bad corner - and one that has frankly stymied nearly all other loot relevance and growth since it's inception. Greensteel has been around for nearly five years now, the majority of this game's life-span - and it's a sad sign of overall game growth and development that it's still king after this much time. They made it too good for it's time - so good they've been afraid to do anything significant since.


I'm bored with Greensteel, and have been for a long time. I'd be happy if we just moved on, or at least didn't fall back on the GS crutch for future loot. I'd frankly rather see the game evolve then reheat the leftovers of the past. And I'd love to see the Devs have the balls to make something that'd shake up loot a bit more then they have.

Greensteel weapons are no longer even remotely competitive at endgame except for triple positives and very niche things (elemental absorb sticks). Accessories, OTOH, are still too good.

Still, the Epic Shroud that got accidentally pushed onto Lamannia was a LOT of fun, and this is coming from someone that is burned out on Shroud. If it were polished a bit I could see it being a top-notch release.

[JOTMON]

The greensteel loot system is the best system they ever invented.

/agreed.

The versatility to build items to fit my playstyle appealed to me much more than building my toon to fit static weapons/gear.

Shroud offered every class build/combination an option to craft equally desirable powerful items (except shields and handwraps).
Every player running shroud would expect to craft 2 or more gear pieces and 2 or more weapons and still be thinking of other variations to make.
Several Shroud items are still usefull through epic and endgame and still not surpassed by endgame drops.

Want to build a dex based rogue light pick user, np craft up a pair of Greensteels.

Try and find decent named light picks in the game... good luck they dont exist, force build your toon to use something else.

Flexibility and versitility has allways been a strong draw for the game in my opinion.



Post Shroud in my opinion the biggest failure from the static loot is the narrow perspective. While probably easier for the design team it funneled players into more restricitive options. My clerics run CiTW already knowing there is nothing of any worth except the hopes of +4 tomes. The rest of Eveninstar is not much better, there is nothing here to keep me coming back for more.

In most cases we are being cattle driven to build toons around endgame gear to achieve endgame greatness.
There is very little wiggle room to build a toon to fit personal vision.
Horc Greatclubs, Dwarven Warhammers, etc.... are not realistically viable endgame options. Sure you can build them but they are flavor gimps vs speccing into specific exisiting endgame named items that have the real power.

I would hope the custom crafting comes back around with epic greensteels, or some variation there of.
All this with the enhancment pass tweaking up racial enhancments and class enhancements.
I want to see a Halfling lightpick dex based rogue (w/dex to damage feats) with epic greensteels and think... oohhh i bet those sneak attack crits hurt.
A Horc w/Epic Greensteel Club next to a Human eSOS wielder and be able to go hmmm....wonder which one does more damage.. i bet its pretty close.....



Looking forward to seeing Feathers makeover of the epic slots/guild slots, I hope will be a corrective rework as opposed to a destructive rework and allow me to build toons to fit my vision and not force me to build the same static toon as everyone else and questing for the exact same weapons/gear.

[BigPapi]

A Horc w/Epic Greensteel Club next to a Human eSOS wielder and be able to go hmmm....wonder which one does more damage.. i bet its pretty close.....

Correct me if I'm wrong, but there's no such thing as a Green Steel Greatclub, is there? Or has this been added?
I made an RPing club wielding dorf barbarian back in the day, so that's the only reason I remember that. Greensteel Maul is only option I know of for 2h bludgeoning.

[JOTMON]

Correct me if I'm wrong, but there's no such thing as a Green Steel Greatclub, is there? Or has this been added?
I made an RPing club wielding dorf barbarian back in the day, so that's the only reason I remember that. Greensteel Maul is only option I know of for 2h bludgeoning.

True the Greatclub was not craftable, but did drop during the festivals, so there are some out there.

Point being there are 38 craftable weapons and 8 craftable gear slots with multiple desirable permutations that can be crafted to suit a players personal build and usable for a large portion of a players life cycle right through to endgame.

Cannith crafting was a step in the right direction, Epic crafting is what I desire to see.