My depressing DDO Day (Renown)

[Glenalth]

But if you have a player who is not fully inactive, who plays one day a month, THAT is when you have to kick them.

Or you get 1 day of play, and 30 days of decay, repeated forever.

I wasn't responding to your issue.

Though on this response, no you don't have to kick them. You only kick them if your guild is only about achieving max level.