OG OG New Raid Meh!!

[Ganak]

No, we're not done with crafting, but that doesn't stop you from starting a separate thread.

New raid?

What have you up your sleeve Mr MadFloyd?

[Shade]

What have you up your sleeve Mr MadFloyd?

As long as they put madfloyd in charge of how difficult elite/epic is, were in good shape. Give him the reigns eladrin.

[Hendrik]

as Long As They Put Madfloyd In Charge Of How Difficult Elite/epic Is, Were In Good Shape. Give Him The Reigns Eladrin.

/signed!

[twiliteslayer02]

I would really like a raid the forces us to work togh\ether in a real teamwork way, not a puzzle, or riddle, i mean a boss that fights for his life, maybe even has an option of escape and ambush as part of its mechanics

( like flaging is done, then enter raid, beat his ass till he squeals, then he bolts, only to ambush the party as they escape the falling ruins themselves, at a random place(totally random not spawn points that are preset))

lots of possibilities, imo, dnd is/was never about puzzles, intrigue yes, drama yes(hello khyber) but not puzzles and riddles and big jugs of hitpoints that basically staqnd there and get hit.

everyone whos ever played pnp has had that moment when they face thier first well played vampire or rakasha, id like to see something like that in this game, a WELL PLAYED enemy.

[Yaga_Nub]

As long as they put madfloyd in charge of how difficult elite/epic is, were in good shape. Give him the reigns eladrin.

I'm a bit late here and trying to catch up but you do realize that Eladrin isn't in charge of dungeon construction right? Eladrin could give him the reins to make a new class though. I think FlimsyFirewood is who you want to talk to.

[Bladedge]

My wish list for future raids

Doesn't have 2/3 of he players being spectators.
Doesn't have a flagging mechanic which you have to run the same quests to get the one missing item that drops randomly or is very rare.
Raid boss is not lured into fighting in one static place through intimidate or dps or is one huge static animated body.
Raid boss that fails to attack or toss the players that are beating on him.
Raid boss that goes after casters and healers.
Raid loot that is not broken, missing abilities or is plain junk.
Raid loot that caters to more then the melee classes.

[Thrudh]

My wish list for future raids

Doesn't have 2/3 of he players being spectators.
Doesn't have a flagging mechanic which you have to run the same quests to get the one missing item that drops randomly or is very rare.
Raid boss is not lured into fighting in one static place through intimidate or dps or is one huge static animated body.
Raid boss that fails to attack or toss the players that are beating on him.
Raid boss that goes after casters and healers.
Raid loot that is not broken, missing abilities or is plain junk.
Raid loot that caters to more then the melee classes.

All these are good... especially this one...

Raid boss is not lured into fighting in one static place through intimidate or dps or is one huge static animated body.

Make it impossible for us to maneuver a boss into hitting just one guy...

Personally, I'd like to see an end-boss situation a lot like part 2 of the Shroud was when it first came out... Let's make it so we have to split the raid party into 3 or 4 groups to win the fight.

[Cam_Neely]

My wish list for future raids

Doesn't have 2/3 of he players being spectators.

I want some sort of puzzle, similar to the 'lights on' puzzle in the shroud, only no one can unlock it. You either take the 5 min to figure out a puzzle and loot, OR you die, and your soul stone goes onto the next part. None of this 4 free chests for dancing by a door please.

[sirgog]

I want some sort of puzzle, similar to the 'lights on' puzzle in the shroud, only no one can unlock it. You either take the 5 min to figure out a puzzle and loot, OR you die, and your soul stone goes onto the next part. None of this 4 free chests for dancing by a door please.

I'm not a fan of puzzles in raids, full stop. If one person solves theirs instantly and another takes 3 minutes, that's a 3 minute 'time out' to the person that instantly solves theirs.

Particularly annoying is the epic VON5 floor tile puzzle, where 3-6 people need to stay there and solve it (and protect the solver) and the rest of the raid have only a limited amount of things they can do until the thing is done.

Puzzles in DDO don't reward brains or character abilities, they reward memorization (for complex floor tile ones), or alt-tabbing out to solvers (Litany questionaire, Monastery end puzzle, Titan preraid).

I do like them in solo/duo/6-player content, however. Less people are forced to pike (or kill endless respawns) while the puzzle is solved.

[RandomKeypress]

Can I put a vote in for easy access to said raid? Getting everyone to the Twilight Forge and the Tower of Despair is a pain in the neck. Even doing shroud was really annoying until airships (thanks for those, btw).

Otherwise - I like hard raids, but can we drop the 'oops, one person doesn't speak english and just killed two of the dogs' and the 'oops, the third column missed the titan' raid failure conditions? I know it adds tension to the game, but when one idiot can mess up an hour's work for eleven other people, it can get frustrating.

I don't have a problem with 'oops, someone broke a crystal, so we've lost two chests' and 'oops, the kiter didn't get shadow agro and now the DPS is getting a bit chilly' errors - you can recover from them. It's the raid failure mechanisms that annoy.

Optional extras are fun, like Suulu in ToD. Over-full unique item lists aren't fun - see complaints re. epic Demon Queen and ToD rings...

[Indoran]

Can I put a vote in for easy access to said raid? Getting everyone to the Twilight Forge and the Tower of Despair is a pain in the neck. Even doing shroud was really annoying until airships (thanks for those, btw).

Otherwise - I like hard raids, but can we drop the 'oops, one person doesn't speak english and just killed two of the dogs' and the 'oops, the third column missed the titan' raid failure conditions? I know it adds tension to the game, but when one idiot can mess up an hour's work for eleven other people, it can get frustrating.

I don't have a problem with 'oops, someone broke a crystal, so we've lost two chests' and 'oops, the kiter didn't get shadow agro and now the DPS is getting a bit chilly' errors - you can recover from them. It's the raid failure mechanisms that annoy.

Optional extras are fun, like Suulu in ToD. Over-full unique item lists aren't fun - see complaints re. epic Demon Queen and ToD rings...

I disagree completely. for different reasons.

1. Its easy to get to ToD
2. Raid failure mechanisms... killing dogs??? A kiter falling is a more serious problem than killing one dog.
3. Not speaking english made someone unable to know a raid? you should have screened him out not because of language, but because of noobness :P. In any case any person should be able to understand this game is about cooperation and if they can't communicate +/- with the group they should look for another group.

[RandomKeypress]

I disagree completely. for different reasons.

1. Its easy to get to ToD
2. Raid failure mechanisms... killing dogs??? A kiter falling is a more serious problem than killing one dog.
3. Not speaking english made someone unable to know a raid? you should have screened him out not because of language, but because of noobness :P. In any case any person should be able to understand this game is about cooperation and if they can't communicate +/- with the group they should look for another group.

Hmm - don't want to jump to conclusions, but I take it you don't PUG much? Yeah, it's easy to get to ToD until someone hasn't been there before. Then I have to drop group and spend a couple of minutes running them there. Seems to be one in every ToD I run. It makes the whole raid wait a minute or two - nothing major, but it's still a nuisance.

The thing about killing dogs is that once they're gone, they're gone. Everyone can be in top form, full mana etc. and it's still a wipe. That is frustrating. We didn't loose, but we can't win.

You cannot screen on comprehension. People play because they want to. They don't tell you that they can't speak/understand. Sometimes they DO understand until it gets a little technical.

[Shade]

The thing about killing dogs is that once they're gone, they're gone. Everyone can be in top form, full mana etc. and it's still a wipe. That is frustrating. We didn't loose, but we can't win.

The dogs do respawn indefinetely.

First one respawns almost instantly, so 1 lost dog shouldnt be an issue.
2nd dog respawns slower, and so on.. Tel lthey take like ~3min to get in.

Course generally runs over ~12 minute are an near-automatic fail as thats the point you get those incredibly tough ancient beholders messing your party up.

Personally I like HARD-Fail conditions like that, really keeps people on there toes and forces strong leadership and teamwork to succeed. due to that hound is among my fav raids. Only issue I have with it is the duration - way way too short.

Tho like I said in my much logner thread on this subecjt here: http://forums.ddo.com/showthread.php?t=322610

Id prefer to have it far more tier'd.. So those hard-fail condition only show up on elite/epic.

[Tinco]

What will we farm this time until our ears bleed? Trinkets? Raids and DDO have always been a troublesome combination in my opinion and while I'm eager to see what you have up your sleeves this time, my hopes aren't exactly high.

[NinjaNeed]

I have an idea for a raid boss encounter, something different from what we have atm:

The mob spawns at the bottom of a large room with a small lake in it, the mob is straight forward tank and spank with 2 exceptions:

He will routinely blind and curse someone, that person will have 10 seconds to jump into the lake and cure their curse or he will explode causing massive aoe damage to the raiding party.

He randomly curses half the raid, while cursed they can not dps the boss at all (it heals him instead) but a second boss, mirror image of the first boss but with only a small amount of HP (similar to one of the red named mobs in Shroud P2). This mirror image can only be damaged by those with the curse and if he gets to the real boss he will explode causing a wipe.

The idea of this is so that all 12 people in the raid have to pay attention to themselves and to others. The second curse could change your eyesight like in Delirum just to make it a bit easier. The healers can ofc continue to heal both parties as needed, the mirror boss does not have massive hp's or hit very hard making it easy to tank by a "squishy".

On harder difficulties the boss's hp's are doubled for each difficulty (so 1 million on normal, 2m on hard, 4m on elite and 8m on epic), he hits for about the same regardless of difficulty (needs to be like this so a 400hp caster/squishy can keep him happy if all the high hp classes cursed onto the mini boss) but he casts his abilities more often at harder difficulty. The blind curse would be three times per kill on normal, 6 on hard, 9 on elite and 12 on epic, and the mini-boss would be summoned every time the main boss looses 750k hp, meaning once on normal, twice on hard, 5 times on elite and a massive 10 times on epic.

Blue bar players would also need some way to keep their power up, maybe make divine spells free due to an aoe buff only available in that room, maybe make the lake that cures the blind curse replenish spell points at a crazy rate.

The loot would need to match the challenge too, choose one slot, say cloak, and have the drop rate increase drastically as with difficulty.

[Maitland]

I love the way you have to flag for quests...for myself,i would like more quests that you have to run out to instead of being tele to..i really cant complain about alot of the raids..you guys do a great job..quests like Titan make alot of ppl think and really have to watch their actions..and i think for that reason,not alot of ppl would want another Titan raid,ha..but i would..anywho...Keep up the great work guys..so far everything you touch is golden..

Bluntt

[Tinco]

quests like Titan make alot of ppl think and really have to watch their actions..and i think for that reason,not alot of ppl would want another Titan raid,ha..but i would..

A lot of people would not want another titan raid because after an exhausting, interesting and well designed preraid, 8/12 people are basically forced to pike in the final encounter. How that is even remotely good raid design is beyond me.

[maddmatt70]

I like the whole concept of defending a fort type raid. It would be something different then the normal raid we have had previously. There would be side objectives such as while defending the fort/castle you have to accomplish certain objectives such as send a group of the raid party out to kill a named boss, send a few out to poison the enemy water supply, etc. , but still have the rest of the party stay and defend the fort against the encroaching hordes.

[toughguyjoe]

Bringing back my suggestion for a raid boss fight. Might not be the final raid boss, for the raid, but I would sure like to see it.


Boss: Purple named Ice Devil.

Spawns: Ice Flensers and Ice Mephits.

Have the boss spawn on a pedestal above the party. Have him talk tough, and then come down for the fight. He himself has two abilities to make the raid harder.

Impale: A high DC fortitude save versus being stunned. Say DC 40 Fort save. Failure results in being stunned for six seconds, and gives a debuff which reduces fortification by 20% for 1 minute.

Ice Prison: He randomly casts Ice Prisons around the room. He targets a player, hits them with it, and Ice forms around them, forming an obstruction. It can be destroyed by melee attacks or spells (Fire deals double damage). This ability is to make the party work together to free important members of the party.

I think these abilities would make foir a dynamic fight, the party having to watch the tank, possibly "Swap out" tanks to wait out the Debuff, and also to be johnny on the spot with saving healers/casters/anyone from Ice Prisons.

[xTethx]

I think Turbine needs to focus a bit more on the 4-6 range for some new content. Then maybe a new raid, but thats just maybe. I mean we had chronoscope out only a year ago, right? I'm all for a new raid, but priorities need to be set more towards the lower lvls.