Here's a suggestion for moving some of the advanced Free to Play players back to VIP: actually give useful, desirable bonuses for paying the VIP fee each month.
As a suggestion, change the raid timer so that VIP's can do a raid after 36 hours instead of 66.
I would venture that there are a ton of long term players (like me) and went free to play and put down a few hundred dollars into TP to buy all the content and now never spend a nickle to support Turbine anymore. But, if i had the chance to run Shroud 3-4 times a week instead of twice, I might be induced to come back since there would be a significant bonus to being VIP.
VIP's are the backbone of the system and I wouldn't begrudge them some nice perks for paying for me to play DDO (the current perks are meh and generally unnecessary for serious players.)
With regard to VIP players suddenly becoming more powerful because they can grind out raids more frequently--so what? It doesn't make me a worse player or less happy if someone else is doing well and it certainly would be nice to be running with groups of players with better gear...
Suggestions/comments welcome.