Quote Originally Posted by Khanyth View Post
anything can be done with enough coordinated effort


Only with unlimited resources and people, of which you have neither.

I agree that the population would drop considerably, but there would be the core base of people who would accept the chalenge. Furthermore, I think it would create a lot of players with alts.

Furthermore, I think there enough benefit (imagine a party wipe as you enter a dungeon... it's like twice the treasure) and if you enter with your guild members that you trust, you can equip a character quite nicely.

And also remember: this eliminates any form of grind that you might encounter. If you have a group of 12 players that you know rock and you've grouped with them many many times, you can do a raid and everyone gets what they want. Hate grinding out ToD or HoX for gear? No more because you can do it once or twice, then you'd never have to do it again if you didn't want to. Hey, it'd also elliminate bad PUGgers too.

This idea rocks more and more as the lines go on
Ok, so what would be the replay value if you could do a quest once or twice and get all the gear you want? How long until the min-maxers figure out a formula to get "everything" in game within days? Where is the value then?

On top of that you want it all for free? just Wow