TOD i rolled for a ring and i didnt recive...

[GregorianPL]

Hey today i have rolled in my TOD group for a ring, guy asked to roll d44 i was only 1 who rolled and he didn't pass it to me he just left a group. I was really disappointed i was seeking for any ring to get an extra 20 % heal amp and when i finally "won" i didnt recive a ring...
here is screenshot
http://img202.imageshack.us/f/d44c.jpg/
what u think about it ? does he deserve for squelch ?

[Droganson]

Sorry but screenshot says roll d123 lowest wins, you rolled a d44 and didn't win.....no need to squelch...

[GregorianPL]

Connor's band d44 are u blind ?

[WielderofGigantus]

Did he leave the ring in the chest or did he loot it and then leave?

[Droganson]

No, and on a second look through I see where you are coming from, but after your attitude, no need to squelch...

[GregorianPL]

he left it in the chest

[Lleren]

He may have you squeltched.

[Droganson]

So he may have accidentilly forgot to change the loot ownership, did you PM after the screenshot about ownership as he/she appears to have dropped group before you exclaimed your position.

[Twitchster]

He may have you squeltched.

What a twist!!!

By M. Night Shyamalan.

[Lorien_the_First_One]

Could just be he missed your roll but...

He may have you squeltched.

That seems likely, or at least he didn't aprove of the OP's conduct in some way and would rather leave it there to make a point to the OP than use it as a second ring or even vendor it for a couple pieces of gold.

[Aegnore]

well technically he still owns the ring and can do whatever he wants to do, that includes whether he wants to give it to someone or not who rolled for it imo

well have you tried sending him a tell or something...

talking about it and clarifying is better than squelching.. =)

Im sorry for your loss

[GregorianPL]

well he didnt left it on his own he gave it to guy with left group

[Aegnore]

well he didnt left it on his own he gave it to guy with left group

then that sux....

btw do we get to have a clue who is this mystery guy? =P

[GregorianPL]

if u want to know send me a pm

[Irongutz2000]

Alll i can say is the barb didn't get his deepwood sniper ring, booo whoooo!!! Suck it up princess

[Lorien_the_First_One]

he left it in the chest

First you say he left it in the chest

well he didnt left it on his own he gave it to guy with left group

Now you say he gave it away.

What do you call someone who changes their story like that?

You have zero cred at this point and that may explain why you didn't get the item.

[harold2560]

the toon you were playing has epic red dragon helm, epic red dragon docent, epic claw set, epic sword of shadows, encrusted ring etc.... and you are complaining about connors band?


wow. just wow.

[Illiain]

What a twist!!!

By M. Night Shyamalan.

Maybe he has the guy who rolled higher than him squelched?

Double twist!!!

[Aegnore]

the toon you were playing has epic red dragon helm, epic red dragon docent, epic claw set, epic sword of shadows, encrusted ring etc.... and you are complaining about connors band?


wow. just wow.

I dont think thats his char... =) unless the one on red armor is his alt... as far as i can recall... greg is a cleric

[Dozen_Black_Roses]

My first impulse is not to squelch. It is not clear if he did leave it in the chest on purpose, or as you later stated gave it to someone else. Since you're not clear here, how can we make sense of it?

The person may have had you squleched therefore not seeing your roles, or maybe they just have not seen it. I have been in raids or quests where an item was put up for roll, I rolled on it, was the only person who rolled on it, and the person is still asking in party chat or voice, so no one wants it? At that point, friends or other party members speak up and see don't you see (Insert my toon's name here) rolled on it? And then they see it, and pass it along. Sometimes it's just a simple mistake, make they have loot rolls coming in general tab instead of party tab, and therefore miss the roll. I wouldn't assume something here.

Now if you sent a tell to him, and asked why didnt you pass it to me, and the response warranted squelching, that's one thing, but that doesn't appear to be the case here, unless you are going to again modify your story.

For future posting, try to include all details as possible in the first post, wherever possible. You may have not meant to be inconsistent in your posts, but this is how it comes across after the fact when you add facts that seem to contradict one another.