Weapon comparison question

[Pikeman]

I am looking for some advice from a combat mechanics guru on which of two weapons I would be better off using when fighting Harry (on normal):

Option #1
LitII Greataxe

Option #2
+5 Metalline Greataxe (note: this is not puregood, but I break DR with it because of the "Weapons of Good" enhancement).

[Jahmin]

"Weapons of Good" enhancement

Two words: Holy Sword

[Pikeman]

Two words: Holy Sword

I am aware that there are other options, but I am interested in knowing which of the listed two is better.

Also, I'm not certain that holy sword is better than the LitII, especially since I can't make a holysword greataxe (which I am kinda set up for).

[Lorien_the_First_One]

Lit II

It' procs for about 600 2-3% of the time, which almost makes up for Harry's DR15, add the higher base damage an its probably a wash at that point with the Met.

It then goes on to add holy and shock that your met does not have.