Min II vs. Lit II

[stille_nacht]

So the way i calculate it, Lit II should do more damage than Min II to harry on a DEX based ranger, therefore, i must be doing something wrong

because harry has Dr 15/silver, Dr 15/good, and Resistance 30 to acid it looks like-

Min II- 1d8 slash, 2d6 good, 1d6 acid burst (ignored), 4d6 acid blast (ignored), 8 STR bonus (i dont expect more), 8 epic bloodstone
4.5 x .3+ 9 x .7 + 7 + 8x.7 +16x.3+ 16x.3=
29.85/swing

Lit II- (1d8slash, 8 STR, 8 epic bloodstone)-15, 2d6 good, 1d6 shocking burst, 4d6 lightning blast, ~650 lightning bolt

(4.5x.7+9x.3+8x.7+16x.3+16x.3)-15 + 7 + 3.5 + 5.5x.3 + 14x.05 + 650 x 0.02=
31.95/swing

am i doing something wrong? or are Lit II really better (at least on norm), because when i linked my lit II rapier to a norm shroud run i was denied :/

[karnokvolrath]

On normal from what ive been told its head no tails.

I actually prefere the lit2 in case you get the boom stick.