* How long did it take you to complete this quest?
Level 20 Sorc, completed in about 30 minutes. Wandered around taking out snipers from the rooftops and generally hopping around the buildings trying not to hit the ground.
* Do you have a clear understanding of the quest story, and was it interesting?
The first part of the quest, defending the wall from the invaders was very clear. Moving out into the city to thin the invaders also made sense. It took me a while to find the sally port (I wasn't expecting a sewer entrance with a switch...I was looking for a GATE from which troops could assault the invaders.) All in all, I had a good time and found the quest fun.
* Were the visuals and environment in this quest appropriate to the theme?
The cityscape under assault was well done.
* Are you likely to run this quest more than once on Live?
* What do you think of the XP and loot rewards given the difficulty of the quest?
The main quest XP was fine. The optionals (rescuing the guards for example) were less than what I would have expected for the time but it probably would have been a lot faster with a group instead of solo so the XP might be proper for group play.
I recieved only random loot rewards, nothing special.
* Please make additional comments here:
It wasn't clear to me that some of the wounded guards were inside the buildings so that optional actually took until after I'd completed the main quest to finish.
Also, I'm not sure about it but if there is an optional named outside the gate that can appear with the other troops then it wasn't clear to me if I needed to go out there or not. If I were on a character at that level, the fight out there would have been quite challenging.
I didn't seem to have to leave much of the area around the wall to complete the quest. It appeared as though so long as you could take out enough of the attackers in the alleys it would progress to the sally port objective. I ended up hitting a Ddoor and stumbling right onto the sally port after looking around the outside for a while. I again think that the difference of solo versus group made it more challenging since only one set of eyeballs in a new quest made it tougher.