PC on +5 holy silver scimmy

[deathtouch]

Can I get a price check on a +5 Holy Silver Scimitar of Human Bane.

Thanks.

[DasLurch]

I'm guessing it's level 16? If so I'd guess around 400-450kpp. I am far from being an expert though.

[sirgog]

Compared to a +5 Metalline of Pure Good Scimitar (generally sells for 350k PP):

3.5 more damage per swing against devils
12.5 more damage per swing against evil humans (not important now, may be in the future)
Doesn't require UMD or good alignment (quite significant for some elven melee builds, particularly FvS builds)
16.5 less damage per swing against Epic Lailat (i.e. it is utterly worthless there)

With all of that in mind - I'd say a pretty fair price is 1.5-2 times what a MoPG scimmy goes for. It's pretty clearly better.

Oh and hold onto this - with halfelves looking really, really strong, Scimitars might just be the new flavor of the month weapon again in a month or so.

[deathtouch]

Woot I guess I will keep hold of it then until the need arises and I need more large scales

[Djimonte]

When I saw the title for your scimmy it interested me but after seeing the bologna prices offered to you and actually seeing what specs is on your scimmy.....
The only two things it has going for it is holy and silver,,,,the human bane turns it into well worthless ineffective wall ornament.
By far and maybe this is where everyone gets confused is if this weapon was holy silver evil outsider (lawful) outsider bane well then yes it would be worth 400k plat at least even transmuting (metaline) would be the same standard at a standing right now
triple pos scimmy beats out holy silver scimmy hands down.... I know I own both on good kotc now adding lawful outsider bane well then it trumps the triple pos scimmy. so yes do not get excited about that there weapon.

[RhapsodieInBlue]

"triple pos scimmy beats out holy silver scimmy hands down"

So you walk into shroud with greensteel already crafted to tier 3?

Congratulations, I'd like to know how you do it.