Why Are guilds DOing this Opinions please

[Gate420]

Sending their members out to smaller guilds and having them befriend the leaders to become an Officer, and when they get their chance deleting all the members out of the Guild. What does this accomplish for them what purpose does this childish behavior serve. I would like to hear all your opinions on this. I for one had this happen and have heard of a few other guilds that they have done this too, One I have never talked to any of their members, I have never had a run in with any of them for them to be angry with me our my guild, and neither did anyone in the guild for all we were concentrating on was leveling and guild membership and renown and gold for getting our guilds airship. I reported it but the game admin said they had no way to track who did it or they would have banned the culprit. I am so angry with that guild I think they should have been disbanded. I do hope that DDO will remove the delete function from officers, they should not have that power anyway IMO

[KoboldKiller]

First off spamming multiple forums with the same thread is a no no.

Secondly, naming specific guilds or players is generally a no no.

Thirdly, as someone pointed out in your other thread be careful whom you make an officer and these things won't happen.

Lastly, if in fact this guild is doing this sort of thing it won't last long as every member will end up being banned by the server.

[Irinis]

I understand that you're angry however naming the guild will give you an infraction on the forums which is now permanent.

[dranreb]

Please stop posting the same topic as multiple threads.

[Khimberlhyte]

Sorry to hear about your misfortune, but realistically, what actual evidence do have proving that it was Thief Guild other than hearsay? My kids have a few characters in that guild, and while all of my level 7-20 characters are in another guild, I have a lowbie cleric in Thief Guild that I only use when I play with my kids. I've only logged in a few times on that character in the past few weeks, but I haven't seen anything promoting the destruction of other guilds on the MoTD when I've looked at it. The MoTD messages I saw were more focused on recruitment and leveling characters.

There are all types of people in online games, including immature griefers who get their kicks by trying to destroy what other people build, or by wrecking a quest (deliberate party wipe, etc). That type of person would gain double the enjoyment by not only destroying your guild, but in assigning the blame to someone else as well. If they successfully do that, then they cause twice the damage - harming your guild, and the reputation of another. Okay, not that Thief Guild has a wonderful reputation to begin with, but I digress....

There are hundreds of people in that guild as well, and I would guess that the majority of them would not want to be associated with someone who would malevolently destroy another guild. Unless someone in a leadership position were to admit to such wrongdoing, or it was a recognizable alt of theirs, you are unlikely to ever know who really did it.

You alone have the power to not promote anyone to officer unless you know them well, and they show a level of commitment and dedication to your guild. You promoted them to officer, and you bear the sole responsibility for that. Depending on how you recruited (blind invites, spamming general chat, constant abuse of LFM panel for recruiting), there are misguided individuals who would feel justified in destroying your guild. This sort of thing has happened before on other servers, and it will happen again until such time as fine-grained controls are available for guild leaders to assign roles to officers.

I would suggest that you don't waste your time finger-pointing without strong evidence, and get back to growing your guild again. You should be able to remember the names of your key members, and re-invite a bunch of them.

Good luck in the future.

[Bloodstealer]

I would hardly think any guild would be so stupid as to actually advertise any such underhand tactics, especially on their own MotD.
Guilds who post lfm's etc to advertise, basically take anything they can get their hands on, especially since the Guild RP system was introduced. In taking on such tactics, they are open to recruiting all manner of attitudes and personalies. I see guilds openely advertising for officers to be recruited of LFM's - that then provides a perfect hunting ground for those players who wish to take on such destructive tom foolery.

I believe the Army of Korthos guild or something similar to that was one of the first to get such harsh treatment, but such open recruitment strategies like we see now, just adds fuel to the fire.
Next thing will be guild chests being looted and players do a runner - so I guess the harsh lesson here is, be more careful who you recruit and how you go about doing it.

That said, I am sorry to hear such a nasty tactic has been used against your guild, but if your guildies have any trust in its leader then will come back to you once they realise it was a deliberate act against the guild and not something you orchestrated. That in itself may help you weed out the individual (s) responsible bu as I am not sure what proof you have tha it was said guild, i am not sure what else you can really do now.

But PM me so that I can at least be forewarned to look out for such players and be more careful about how you post details on the forums in future, its likely to land you in more trouble.

[LordMond]

The only reason that comes to my mind is that, if the 'leader' essentially disbands the smaller Guilds, this leads to an increase of 'ronin' if you will and at least some of those might join the large Guild that you mention (or one that does something similar), thus making that Guild larger and increasing the number of members earning Renown.

Personally, I'd rather see a Guild grow because they have decent (in terms of skill and personality) players.

[Gate420]

Don't see how it posted multiple times except that I was having trouble making posts when the servers where down this morning so perhaps when it said post not made and i clicked it again it had been made. I don't know because I only posted this here and no where else as far as I know I only made this post here. The other post I made was in suggestions. I said it was them because they said so in the daily message and I am angry that they did this and want to know why they would do this now I guess they could have been framed in that case ppl still need to know this is happening and there needs to be a way to track the movements of officers or the delete function to be removed for if it really was another guild that did it and said it was the thiefs guild,
What if they all get banned because of the actual guild that is doing it.
This is why I made the post to make it get known I feel this is very bad for all involved my guild and thier guild. If they truly are not responsible like it said in the daily message, is this not cause for concern and a cause to have things changed I mentioned the guilds name because it seemed to me that who did it was proud of themselves for they left the guilds signature in the daily message and I figured if they truly are not responsible they may actually help me in getting the delete function removed from Officers or some kind of log for who is deleted and recruited and by whom so I hope this makes sense and clears up why I said what I said. How would you like it if I became your friend spent all the time making you trust me then as soon as you turn your back delete all your members. With you having no way to know which of your friends that you have made as an officer did it, its not right its not proper and there is a much better way to protect guild's from this if they just do one or the other of my suggestions. It is a long post but I wanted to cover everything I read in the above post's.

[Hobgoblin]

Don't see how it posted multiple times except that I was having trouble making posts when the servers where down this morning so perhaps when it said post not made and i clicked it again it had been made. I don't know because I only posted this here and no where else as far as I know I only made this post here. The other post I made was in suggestions I said it was them because they said so in the daily message and I am angry that they did this and want to know why they would do this now I guess they could have been framed in that case ppl still need to know this is happening and there needs to be a way to track the movements of officers or the delete function to be removed for if it really was another guild that did it and said it was the thiefs guild what if they all get banned because of the actual guild that is doing it this is why I made the post to make it get known I feel this is very bad for all involved my guild and thier guild if they truly are not responsible like the it said in the daily message, is this not cause for concern and a cause to have things changed I mentioned the guilds name because it seemed to me that who did it was proud of themselves for they left the guilds signature in the daily message and I figured if they truly are not responsible they may actually help me in getting the delete function removed from Officers or some kind of log for who is deleted and recruited and by whom so I hope this makes sense and clears up why I said what I said how would you like it if I became your friend spent all the time making you trust me then as soon as you turn your back delete all your members and you have no way to know which of your friends that you have made did it its not right its not proper and there is a much better way to protect guild if they just do one or the other

Combat: wall of text hits your party member, Hobgoblin, for 9898979039033 pts of damage
Combat: your party member, Hobgoblin, has died

(transtation: walls of text are bad and make your post be taken less seriously then it might deserve.)

hob

[Gate420]

Combat: wall of text hits your party member, Hobgoblin, for 9898979039033 pts of damage
Combat: your party member, Hobgoblin, has died

(transtation: walls of text are bad and make your post be taken less seriously then it might deserve.)

hob

so I had to write alot to cover it all

[Falco_Easts]

Don't see how it posted multiple times except that I was having trouble making posts when the servers where down this morning so perhaps when it said post not made and i clicked it again it had been made. I don't know because I only posted this here and no where else as far as I know I only made this post here. The other post I made was in suggestions I said it was them because they said so in the daily message and I am angry that they did this and want to know why they would do this now I guess they could have been framed in that case ppl still need to know this is happening and there needs to be a way to track the movements of officers or the delete function to be removed for if it really was another guild that did it and said it was the thiefs guild what if they all get banned because of the actual guild that is doing it this is why I made the post to make it get known I feel this is very bad for all involved my guild and thier guild if they truly are not responsible like the it said in the daily message, is this not cause for concern and a cause to have things changed I mentioned the guilds name because it seemed to me that who did it was proud of themselves for they left the guilds signature in the daily message and I figured if they truly are not responsible they may actually help me in getting the delete function removed from Officers or some kind of log for who is deleted and recruited and by whom so I hope this makes sense and clears up why I said what I said how would you like it if I became your friend spent all the time making you trust me then as soon as you turn your back delete all your members and you have no way to know which of your friends that you have made did it its not right its not proper and there is a much better way to protect guild if they just do one or the other

For a challange, how far can you get through reading this sentence aloud in one breath?

EDIT : Now it is edited to be 2 sentences you get a breath in the middle.

While I feel for you OP, you have no one to blame but the leader who promoted them to Officer. Yeah it sucks but if you are going to recruit/promote people you don't know well/at all then things like this are going to happen. I would reconmend looking at your recruitment/promotion methods.

[Gate420]

For a challange, how far can you get through reading this sentence aloud in one breath?

My fault they don't add the periods and commas that I have there.

[Bloodstealer]

My fault they don't add the periods and commas that I have there.

Gate, as I said earlier in your thread, maybe see this as a learning experience - consider how and who you recruit in future - guild renown is merely just a new grind but everyone gets the same thing out of it.... maybe not today, maybe not tomorrow, but some day... dang I need to watch some better movies

Build your guild around players you know and trust in game... it takes a while but guiild reputations take a long time to build and only seconds to destroy. Much the same as what has happened to you here, except it wasnt just your guild rep that got destroyed.

Good luck tho getting things back on track

[Gate420]

Gate, as I said earlier in your thread, maybe see this as a learning experience - consider how and who you recruit in future - guild renown is merely just a new grind but everyone gets the same thing out of it.... maybe not today, maybe not tomorrow, but some day... dang I need to watch some better movies

Build your guild around players you know and trust in game... it takes a while but guiild reputations take a long time to build and only seconds to destroy. Much the same as what has happened to you here, except it wasnt just your guild rep that got destroyed.

Good luck tho getting things back on track

I have done so and we are up and running fine it was not my guild rep that was destroyed its the guild being blamed for it that is losing their reputation, and my concern is this if it truly was not them and it truly was another guild.
I would hate for them to be disbanded or Banned because of another guild. I would like to see a function added for guild Leaders to have better control Possibly even just adding a recruiter so you can have many recruiters and few Officers in any case this is all about getting it known to all that this type of thing is happening to many guilds and it is being told that the other guild mentioned is responsible. It would seem that none of you understand the whole point of why I am doing this! Or maybe the point is being lost in any case thanks for your encouragement.

[Bloodstealer]

I have done so and we are up and running fine it was not my guild rep that was destroyed its the guild being blamed for it that is losing their reputation, and my concern is this if it truly was not them and it truly was another guild.
I would hate for them to be disbanded or Banned because of another guild. I would like to see a function added for guild Leaders to have better control Possibly even just adding a recruiter so you can have many recruiters and few Officers in any case this is all about getting it known to all that this type of thing is happening to many guilds and it is being told that the other guild mentioned is responsible. It would seem that none of you understand the whole point of why I am doing this! Or maybe the point is being lost in any case thanks for your encouragement.

I think we all understand what your trying to tell us - beware their are rogues out there... (pardon the pun you guys from the other guild ).
Having only been stateside since Dec 09 I am yet to get to know alot of the guilds out there but unfirtunatley I have heard a few tales of this kind of behaviour but the issue is proving it and getting Turbine to look into it for the proof you need.

What I think I and others have basically tried to say is that is sucks it has happened, it should not have but at present there isn't alot you can actually do if Turbine are not pepared or not able to do anything about it.

The only thing they could do is serve you an infraction for using another guilds name and openly flaming them on here.

Although an inconvenience, I am sure it wont take long as I said to re-recruit those who got displaced - those that dont.. well your list of suspects basically got shorter - not that it will serve any purpose.

I personally only give out officer roles to players I genuenly trust and have known a fair while in game or in RL but unfortuantely with the guild RP system, many guilds have taken a speed root to renown and forgotten alot of the traditional values of a guild... each to their own, but this thread at least serves as a warning to all guild leaders.

Good luck

[Falco_Easts]

Your just an infantile who must need a life and you obviously are not a nice person I have not read what you said because I can't none of my posts are filled with errors. I may lack Punctuation but most forums I have been too didn't care about such things as some seem to here. But even still I have kept all my posts to the points yours who knows and should just be removed. If there is any advice in their I think you should take it for yourself good luck you are going to need it I did catch one little thing on your childish post. I know they didn't leave because it takes an officer to put in the daily message we have deleted your members from the ***** GUILD and the members who came back told me they were kicked also my alts where kicked. Pretty hard for my alts to get up and leave the guild with all other 200 members..

I know it sounds harsh but take it on board. I don't know about other forums but if you want to be taken seriously on these forums, spelling and puncuation are a must.

[Waukeen]

I know it sounds harsh but take it on board. I don't know about other forums but if you want to be taken seriously on these forums, spelling and puncuation are a must.

QFT.
Just take sometime and compose some slightly constructed prose; it seems like you are blurting on the page.

[Holymosher]

dude , im a officer in the guild, and it not us dude honestly your not the first person to make a forum like this, about our guild, if we did it why would we leave our names to become hated? no, it obviously someone who is jealous of the guild and trying to demolish us, which is so childish, like honestly man you think ppl would commit murders and leave there names at the scene?

[unscythe]

dude , im a officer in the guild, and it not us dude honestly your not the first person to make a forum like this, about our guild, if we did it why would we leave our names to become hated? no, it obviously someone who is jealous of the guild and trying to demolish us, which is so childish, like honestly man you think ppl would commit murders and leave there names at the scene?

dude.....Dude....DUDE!!!!!!!

j/k


Sorry for the OP, but how long does it take for a player to trust another? I mean making someone you just met and calling them a friend, and then making them an officer seems pretty silly.

It is sad, but sometimes it helps to have some standards/thought before making such decisions. People that ask to be officers in a guild should not be officers.

[Stitch78]

Your just an infantile who must need a life and you obviously are not a nice person I have not read what you said because I can't...

Sigh. I nominate this sentence for the ironic-exclamation-of-the-month club.

(The winning statement's author is automatically enrolled in a jelly-of-the-month club, so maybe, OP, this will be a case of "all's well that ends well.")

[DISCLAIMER: Not available to residents of AK, HI, NJ, NY, Fiji, the British Virgin Islands or my parents. No purchase necessary to enter. Limit one entry per OP. Official rules can be found by searching the internet. Jelly is not guaranteed to be other than grape. Do not store jelly in places likely to exceed 62 degrees Farenheit. Do not eat jelly. Club entries are not vetted for sarcasm. Void where prohibited and in Canada.]