I only cash coins in at the Harbor. You could cash in at House P. I cash coins in Instance 1 always.
Usual caveats apply. In no way am I inferring that my results will be the same as your results. I am sure you all will get more recipe 5s than I do per 100 coins.
For those of you that notice the percentages do not add up to 100 it is because on rare chances, three white coins can give you two rewards. Two blue coins can give you three rewards. Also, I am not listing all the rewards for time savings. When I come back from vacation I wil list it all for completeness.
4,212 white Coins Turned in
Recipe 1 = 89, 6.34%
Recipe 3 = 94, 6.70%
Recipe 6 = 94, 6.70%
Recipe 7 = 50, 3.56%
Recipe 8 = 53, 3.77%
Recipe 16 = 72, 5.13%
Candy Canes = 55, 3.92%
Potion, Haste = 30, 2.14%
Potion, Jump = 43, 3.06%
Potion, Chill Shield = 36, 2.56%
Potion, Resist Fire = 30, 2.14%
Potion, Protection Fire = 39, 2.78%
Potion, Frostbite - 46, 3.28%
Potion, superior Freeze - 47, 3.35%
Potion, Feather Fall - 46, 3.28%
Motes = 37.70 winter motes per 100 white coins
Max number of motes for 3 white coins = 6 winter motes
Scroll, Niacs - 11, 0.78%
Scroll, Snowballs - 11, 0.78%
Scroll, Frost Lance - 20, 1.42%
Scroll, Ice Storm - 17, 1.21%
Scroll, Cone of Cold - 42, 2.99%
Scroll, Otiluke's Freezing Sphere - 23, 1.64%
Scroll, Polar Ray - 13, 0.93%
Wand, Niacs - 31, 2.21%
Wand, Ice Storm - 12, 0.85%
Wand, Cone of Cold - 12, 0.85%
__________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __
4,366 Blue Coins Turned in
Recipe 1 = 165, 7.56%
Recipe 2 = 188, 8.61%
Recipe 3 = 152, 6.96%
Recipe 4 = 101, 4.63%
Recipe 6 = 126, 5.77%
Recipe 7 = 100, 4.58%
Recipe 8 = 88, 4.03%
Recipe 9 = 109, 4.99%
Recipe 10 = 75, 3.44%
Recipe 11 = 35, 1.60%
Recipe 15 = 204, 9.34%
Recipe 16 = 116, 5.31%
Candy Canes = 84, 3.85%
Potion, Haste = 91, 4.17%
Potion, Jump = 88, 4.03%
Potion, Chill Shield = 96, 4.40%
Potion, Resist Fire = 90, 4.12%
Potion, Protection Fire = 63, 2.89%
Potion, Frostbite - 112, 5.13%
Potion, superior Freeze - 72, 3.30%
Potion, Feather Fall - 76, 3.48%
Motes = 522.84 winter motes per 100 blue coins
Max number of motes for 2 blue coins = 20 winter motes
Scroll, Niacs - 42, 1.92%
Scroll, Snowballs - 47, 2.15%
Scroll, Frost Lance - 38, 1.74%
Scroll, Ice Storm - 50, 2.29%
Scroll, Cone of Cold - 51, 2.34%
Scroll, Otiluke's Freezing Sphere - 37, 1.69%
Scroll, Polar Ray - 49, 2.24%
Wand, Niacs - 74, 3.39%
Wand, Ice Storm - 27, 1.24%
Wand, Cone of Cold - 24, 1.10%
__________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __
1,182 Purple Coins Turned in
Recipe 1 = 83, 7.02%
Recipe 2 = 92, 7.78%
Recipe 3 = 71, 6.01%
Recipe 4 = INCOMPLETE I forgot to write down the final number and I did things afterwards that I have no idea on
Recipe 5 = 62, 5.25%
Recipe 6 = 79, 6.68%
Recipe 7 = 76, 6.43%
Recipe 8 = 39, 3.30%
Recipe 9 = 57, 4.82%
Recipe 10 = 36, 3.05%
Recipe 11 = 27, 2.28%
Recipe 12 = 66, 5.58%
Recipe 13 = 54, 4.57%
Recipe 14 = 31, 2.62%
Recipe 15 = 107, 9.05%
Recipe 16 = 48, 4.06%
Recipe 17 = 31, 2.62%
Recipe 18 = 41, 3.47%
Recipe 19 = 48, 4.06%
Recipe 20 = 47, 3.98%
Candy Canes = 121, 10.24%
Potion, Haste = 87, 7.36%
Potion, Jump = 83, 7.02%
Potion, Chill Shield = 120, 10.15%
Potion, Resist Fire = 107, 9.05%
Potion, Protection Fire = 100, 8.46%
Potion, Frostbite - 121, 10.24%
Potion, superior Freeze - 114, 9.64%
Potion, Feather Fall - 103, 8.71%
Motes = 2124.11 winter motes per 100 purple coins
Max number of motes per purple coin = 40 winter motes
Scroll, Niacs - 51, 4.31%
Scroll, Snowballs - 38, 3.21%
Scroll, Frost Lance - 74, 6.26%
Scroll, Ice Storm - 33, 2.79%
Scroll, Cone of Cold - 46, 3.89%
Scroll, Otiluke's Freezing Sphere - 53, 4.48%
Scroll, Polar Ray - 51, 4.31%
Wand, Niacs - 77, 6.51%
Wand, Ice Storm - 26, 2.20%
Wand, Cone of Cold - 24, 2.03%