Guild chests on airship!

[ahpook]

As far as I know, the guild chest are optional. If the chest access doesn't work for your guild, don't put one in your ship. That seems pretty simple to me.

If you want to propose a different chest that has restricted access at a different reward level, go for it. But don't change the current one because it doesn't work for you. It works great for some guilds. It lets us borrow items in a reasonable manner rather than waiting for the leader to come on and assign it.

Here's a way that doesn't involve clunky access control lists.

Just have a "chest log". For every item passing through the chest in the last 3 days, keep track of who deposited and who pulled it out. Every member is limited to 10 deposits/withdrawals a day, officers unlimited. Basically, we need accountability more than we need control. Any group of more than 2 members is already somewhat anonymous.

I would agree that logging would be superior to controls as well and would be nice to have.

[Merlocke]

..or just dont be an LFM recruitment guild.

[donfilibuster]

Here's another idea without access control: flag the items in the same way of the 'starter' flag.
The items in the chest are intended to be used, not sold, this is a main purpose of putting them for grabs on the first place.
It'd be like a Bound to Guild item minus the access check, you can still give them away just can't be sold.

Naturally you then can't use the chest for hagglebots, but maybe u can do the branding off chest (like altar) and that'd be solved.
It even has PnP equivalent, the Wizard Mark spell served that very purpose.

[TheDearLeader]

..or just dont be an LFM recruitment guild.

We're not, thanks for playing. Now back on topic...

A transaction log would be nice. I wouldn't mind if it announced it in /g

Example : Mcphail (Sor 20, Member) has deposited 10 Vials of Pure Water into your guild chest.
(The item is hotlinked automatically, can be clicked)
Kiarnan (Ftr 20, Member) has withdrawn 10 Soul Gems : Essence of Earth from your guild chest.

That by itself would be nice.

[anto_capone]

This. I'm glad to see this is not only on our ship. The level 25 small chest (non-gold seal) says its accessible by all members but only the leader and officers can access it. It looked to me that the level 28 small chest was the one that was supposed to have restricted access. Anyone seen anything where they are working on this?

Would be nice to make the chest accessible to all members (like it says it should), making everyone an officer of the guild is tedious for me.

Any word on it? Maybe in next update?

Thx

[anto_capone]

is there any fix to this?

our chest is the level 25 one, and only officers and leader can access it. was hoping the whole guild could access it like description says, instead of making everyone an officer :P