Greensteel Fighter Questions

[English_Warrior]

My Kensei Maul THF Fighter has just become flagged for the Shroud...so its time to look into what Greensteel weapon I want to eventually craft...and I have a few questions about it.

I have decided upon a Mineral II Maul....for obvious reasons.

The dilemma I have is what else to put onto the weapon. I know I need to have either Holy or Good for DR bypass....but which is more useful....and what should I add to it?

Should I go:
Holy + Acid Blast + Acid Burst
Holy + Acid Burst + exc Con 2
Good burst + Elemental Acid + Acid Blast
Good burst + Elemental Acid + exc Con 2

or maybe some other configuration I haven't thought of?


The second question I have is: Both Acid Blast and Acid Burst produce 2d10 extra acid damage on a critical....do these both stack to make 4d10....or do they not and just stay 2d10?
Same question with the Acid blasts extra 4d6 on a confirmed natural 20...does that stack with all the other critical acid damage too?

[English_Warrior]

I did some basic calculations to check the damage difference between Holy/Acid/Acid and Good/Acid/Acid:

On a non critical hit against an evil creature:
Holy = +10.5 damage per hit
Good = +7.0 damage per hit

On a critical hit against an evil creature:
Holy = +32.5 damage per hit
Good = +32.0 damage per hit

However:

On a non critical hit against a non-evil creature:
Holy = +3.5 damage per hit
Good = +7.0 damage per hit

On a critical hit against a non-evil creature:
Holy = +25.5 damage per hit
Good = +32.0 damage per hit

I think I'm leaning towards Good/Acid/Acid......Any thoughts?

[pasterqb]

I would agree with Good/Acid/Acid. Mostly cause Con can easily be put on a ToD ring even though it might take a while to get. Also taking Exceptional Con will increase your health which frankly should be pretty high being a fighter and would lower your dps a good amount. If you are looking for health you can just make a 45hp item which i suggest cloak.