Originally Posted by
dkyle
If you're not going to pursue AC actively, forget about it. You need a lot of AC for it to matter at all past level 10 or so.
As for DPS, the strongest DPS Pali is a pure Pali. The strongest DPS fighter is a pure fighter or a 12ftr/6rngr/2[rog/mnk]. Pali and Fighter don't really mix that well.
So, neither build you're talking about is going to rule DPS, and 4 Pali is pretty useless as far as support. I'd say stick with 2rog/4ftr/14pali. It fits your goal better than the alternative.
Besides, the main reason for 12ftr is Kensai II, which gives a +8 str clicky. DMII, which you can get by 14 pali, gives +4 damage. Ignoring attack bonus, they're the same damage. The attack bonus is partially made up for by Divine Favor.