Let us decide what we want from the collectors

[Sintwar]

Apparently the collectibles that we gather, are something that the collectors actually want and "need". So why then do we hand them things that they want and need, and in return, have to stick our hand in a grab bag, and pull out some misc. thing in return?

When I make a trade with someone, it is usually because I am giving them something they want, and getting something that I want in exchange.

I would like to see something like the reward selection that is offered when you complete a quest when I offer a trade with the collectors.

[sirgog]

Apparently the collectibles that we gather, are something that the collectors actually want and "need". So why then do we hand them things that they want and need, and in return, have to stick our hand in a grab bag, and pull out some misc. thing in return?

When I make a trade with someone, it is usually because I am giving them something they want, and getting something that I want in exchange.

I would like to see something like the reward selection that is offered when you complete a quest when I offer a trade with the collectors.

This brings an image to mind of an end reward list with twelve different Scrolls of Suggestion for you to choose between....

[Baahb3]

I can see where you are going with this, instead of getting that repair light potion for your 3 mushrooms when you are not a warforged or getting those 20 bolts of giant bane when you are holding a bow, you actually get to choose the one that you want.

Good suggestion.

[Shamurai]

that would be nice.. and if it did "One Type" all at once.. so I could turn in 30 of those wavecraher books for a pile of CMW wands for my cleric all in one pop.

[Turial]

...
I would like to see something like the reward selection that is offered when you complete a quest when I offer a trade with the collectors.

I could see something like random items for the set of 3 collectables, a pair of items for the set of 2, and a choice of 4 items for the 1 of collectables.

Make it a little less grab-bag but not all that hot either.

The problem with collectables is that they never really did much with them and some quests don't even have nodes to gather from.