well now i melee in shroud part 1 simply because fingering everything is generally not possible. what i do is i zone in an melee like all the other tanks do. but after everyone is on the portal and i'm soloing THEN i finger of death and phantasmal killer everything until there is only one melee opponent left (always finger the casters) and then i just beat him down with wounders, fire shield, (was using hold person for a while, but i find even with extend it might be long enough), and usually they go down quick.