
Originally Posted by
Hahr Jinn
You.
Fable 2 is definitely fun, but very easy. It's much more an action RPG than an RPG. The interface is very straight-forward and really starts to shine as you become more powerful. The aimed ranged ability and the charging magic is fun.
That said, I've already beaten and traded in Fable2. There really isn't much to do once you beat the main quest, and, enjoyable as the interface is, there's little to no strategy in the battles. It's fun, for a bit, but it's easily beatable w/ most of the achievements in a solid week or two' playing, and there's not much to go back for.
The coop, such as it is, is abysmal, so don't pick it up if that's a deciding factor. The 2nd character joins s a generic henchman w/o any of the really enjoyable abilities. Also, the camera goes from free control to a constant angle that can be re-centered by either party. It really bites. If silly little things like decapitations, buying property, and posing while farting for statues are your cup of tea, this will be a good romp.
As for Fallout 3, I can't say as much as I'm only a few hours and 5 levels (out of 20) in. It is a very different shooter, but very much like Oblivion w/ guns, except for the V.A.T.S. combat system which allows you to pause at times to line up a few attacks.
In complete contrast to Fable, Fallout is very difficult, bringing back a lot of Obl's nuances, like degrading equiptment, an open-ended, sandbox world that can overwelm you in an instant, and an early shortage of useful equiptment; in addition, the ubiquitous and useless real world items that you can sell for a buck (or a bottlecap in this case) are back, making maximizing Fallout a lot of run, retrive to carry weight max, and run back again.
Fallout also starts much more slowly than Fable, so if you want to jump in and kill some stuff, Fable's probably the better choice. Even 5 levels in, you still have to be very careful about encounters in Fallout and approach them methodically, as very few kills give commensuate equiptment or xp. I've found Fallout to be a lot of fun, but certainly not a blast, and have powered down the xbox on a number of occaisions due to how hard it is to maximize your play in an encounter.
Finally, in terms of variety, the games offer a mixed bag in that you'll need to replay Fallout (or buy the guide) to really be decent in most of the skills, whereas it's very simple to be good at Fable's 3 offerings: might, magic, and boomstick. Fable's replay value, though, is nil to me.
Bang for the buck? Fallout, hands down.
Enjoybale romp through a baddy's viscera? Fable (though Fallout is as gratuitously gorey as I've seen). Fallout is just too slow to be called a romp.
I certainly don't sell myself as a master gamer, but Fallout is as tough of an Xbox 360 game as I've played. I'd suggest renting Fable and buying Fallout, though buying Fable and trading it for Fallout is viable as well.
Considering your previous posts on Tool, I'd expect you to enjoy the complexity, irony, and methodical nature of Fallout more than the instant gratification and simple pleasures of Fable.