Quote Originally Posted by choklitwayne View Post
value is in the eye of the buyer. i personally have not made any requests, merely suggestions. i find it amusing that someone actually LOOKING FOR q-staffs is getting high and mighty. i'll give u all the ones i pull for free, but it's always in the best interest of ANY trade for each participant to attempt to get the best price possible. unfortunately, sarcasm and condescending comments only purchase more of the same. but, gl though.
Not really. In your case value is in the crit range of the weapon when it comes to those with crit based effects. You offered up a blunt banisher which only crits on a 20 (19-20 if IC: Bludgeoning is taken) and were looking for +2 tomes, large ingredients, tome/shield pieces, or plat (and I'm guessing by "plat" you meant > 100k pp). There is the matter of "attempting to get the best price possible" and then there is reality. How often do you see blunt heavy maces/light maces/morningstars getting traded here for that kind of stuff? Exactly, you don't.