Shroud/Vision Finessables

[AkromaAoW]

I'm just curious on this one. It seems that I have come into a couple of finessable weapons that are suited for the Shroud and Vision:

+2 transmuting shortsword of greater evil outsider bane
+3 transmuting light hammer of greater evil outsider bane

I am interested in hearing thoughts on the value of these in terms of large ingredients.

Thanks!

[Darkwolf1071]

Hmm. Obviously I'd think the SS would be more valuable than the light hammer. Unfortunately I think that the builds that would find them the most useful (IE rogues, rangers, squishier type builds) probably wouldn't be using them on Sulu; most people seeming to want to go with the hero/dual hero method on him. Aside from that people seem to want vorpal/stat damage for everything but the red named Orthons in Visions. If I were to have one of those I'd probably only use it on them (red named orthons) and on Harry. Don't know that either would be as good as a Mineral 2 weapon of the same type, though now that I've said that someone will probably do the number crunching and prove me wrong.

I think if you found someone who was yet to craft/dual craft weapons in the Shroud the SS might go for 2 scales or 1 scale and 2 or 3 others. Light hammer, again, not as much.

[AkromaAoW]

Hmm. Obviously I'd think the SS would be more valuable than the light hammer. Unfortunately I think that the builds that would find them the most useful (IE rogues, rangers, squishier type builds) probably wouldn't be using them on Sulu; most people seeming to want to go with the hero/dual hero method on him. Aside from that people seem to want vorpal/stat damage for everything but the red named Orthons in Visions. If I were to have one of those I'd probably only use it on them (red named orthons) and on Harry. Don't know that either would be as good as a Mineral 2 weapon of the same type, though now that I've said that someone will probably do the number crunching and prove me wrong.

I think if you found someone who was yet to craft/dual craft weapons in the Shroud the SS might go for 2 scales or 1 scale and 2 or 3 others. Light hammer, again, not as much.

I dont think they have so much value on normal with the other options that are available, but perhaps on hard or elite they become more useful. I would like to hear from the number crunchers :-).