I just hit a critical Exalted Smite 3 with a +11 to damage on a Transmuting righteous heavy pick. I only did 90 damage.
That seems to me to be virtually impossible.
90 damage/6 multiplier is 15 points of damage. The MINIMIM damage from the weapon is 12. If the reaver is evil, then that is 14. I find it hard to believe that only three points of damage is added by 15 levels of paladin....
Back about a year ago, I was doing 230+ with just the physical damage on a critical holy smite.
Anyone else have this issue?