Originally Posted by
SUPERCREWJOHN
Ok so if switch Mithril for Adamantine What advantage does the Evasion have? My dex is only 14 ( +2)
From the compendium:
When you make a successful Reflex save to avoid damage, you suffer no damage instead of half damage.
Given an effective reflex save, and functional Evasion, you have the potential to mitigate damage from spells and traps that allow you a reflex save. Presumably, a poor reflex save reduces the usefulness of evasion. Adamantine Plating negates the benefit of Evasion.
Mithril gives an armor bonus of 5, with a max dex bonus of 5, adamantine gives 8 with max dex bonus of 1. That's a base armor bonus difference of 3; perhaps significant at lower levels. As your level and dexterity increase you have to consider the point where Adamantine restricts your AC more than helps it.
Sooo....
With a 14 Dex bonus of +2 and no shield:
Mithril 10+5 +3 (docent), +2 (dex) 20
Adamant 10+8 +3 (docent), +1 (dex) 22
Currently a 2 pt difference, and what will you face at levels 5, 6, 7, & higher that will require a good reflex save coupled with evasion?