Price Check Please

[Paladin20]

I would like an appraisal/unbiased analysis on the value of a +1 Banishing Rapier of Puncturing (no RR, lvl 14), either in PP or placement relative to other ubers. Thanks!

[Eldun]

Sweet item ... definately will fetch over 800K plat I'd imagine. The banishers are about 600k and toss in some more to reduce one extra bank space. I wouldn't value it much higher because after all it is only one extra bank slot and a puncturing rapier can be gotten for cheap.

[Boldrin]

I would have to say 750K-1 million plat... At least that's what it would go for on Khyber

[Kamboe]

the puncturing isnt much of an add on.....i guess some do save....they go for 5-6 larges on khyber

[darkrune]

IMO the value is VERY high right now somewhere in the lines of 5+ Large, 500k+pp, some may disagree but these make devils runs and most of the vale stuff a cakewalk in the right hands...

Dont take less as someone will pay that (just not me)

[brshelton]

come to sarlona and ill make you happy

[draeconius]

This is indeed a nice item. Pls post a want list. I would love to trade ya for it. let me know what you need.

[gaxpar]

Just try it on the auction i say not less then 1 mill plat but i am sure 19 million/20 million buyout doesnt sit there a 3 day cycle u make 14 millions gold ,a lot of people dont come to the forums .

This banisher will vanish on the auction man .

Good luck man i cant think of any Suffixe right now better on the banisher than puncturing ,i mean a straight puncturing rapier with a crappy prefixe will sell for 50 k to 100 k plat... Can anyone name a better suffixe than puncturing on the banisher ? any suffixe?


Just be patient and keep posting it man it will go its just a matter of time and as far as ingredients goes ,since almost everyone does a daily shroud the value is declining at a free fall speed so i would go for straight plat, be patient give it 4-6 weeks and large will go for 50 k plat buyout ...

Then you should be able to buy all you need for tier one ,2 and three for a couple toons go in there with all you need craft whatever you need and then you wont need to grind the shroud you ll be able to run it when you feel like it .

This is strictly an opinion but its good as any ...

[DaveyCrockett]

I have 2 of those on Argonnessen. One I looted, one I paid 1.4 million plat for.

I would pay 2 million for another.

Not sure how Thelanis' economy is sitting atm, but it should bring way more than 5 large or 500k pp as suggested in earlier posts.

-DfC

[~Inotna]

People from other servers need to stay on their own servers! The economy from server to server are very different. I would say about 1 million pp for this item based on the current recession we are experiencing on Thelanis. As far as price goes name it and I'll pay it for this weapon if you end up selling it.

[Byzantian]

The value of items on other servers compared to ours (Thelanis) is completely irrelevant.

I would trade for that Banisher because of the Puncturing add on.

But you cant really keep using plat as a value meter, plat is the easiest thing to get in DDO, is'nt it....

[sirgog]

Can anyone name a better suffixe than puncturing on the banisher ? any suffixe?

A high Backstab rating is the only thing I can think of. That or a higher + rating on the weapon.

Puncturing is good in that it will work well if you accidentally forget to change weapons when fighting non-Outsider foes.

[JFeenstra]

backstabbing and pure good would be two things i'd rather have on a banishing rapier than puncturing

its still a nice item though

[sirgog]

backstabbing and pure good would be two things i'd rather have on a banishing rapier than puncturing

its still a nice item though

Why add pure good?

With a 15-20 banisher, adding 1d6 damage is near-on useless, as the mob will almost certainly fail a Banish save before it takes enough HP damage to matter. I'd rather a +2 banisher than a +1 banisher of pure good (more likely to confirm the crit).

Puncturing on the other hand is lethal quickly enough that it may kill something will high Will saves.

[gaxpar]

backstabbing and pure good would be two things i'd rather have on a banishing rapier than puncturing

its still a nice item though

Can't understand the mathematics for pure good .

Even backstabbing unless its a +5 wich that would make it a minimum level 20 weapon .But even then the gain from backstabbing is far from puncturing rapier for any pierce specced toon do 1 d 6 con damage every 4 hits averaging 3 points of con every 4 swings that will be more than backstabbing because unless u are in WW 6 points of con in 8 hits is way more hp(>24 points of pure good damage ), that an average of 3 points of pure good average in 8 hits.(24 hp )

When talking about mobs with 500-2000 hp .(level 12 -16 mobs average) with a maximum of 34 con for most of those mobs .Theres a lot more hp associated to 2 points of con damage then a 1 d6 pure good or backstabb will ever get .

Unless theres something you know that we dont it is hard to understand your logic especially with pure good .

If we are talking about a barbarian that crits 35% of the time then backstabbing and pure good are more than completely irrelevant ...

So if you could just explain the logic behind it maybe theres something we fail to see or understand .It wont be the first or the last time anyway ...

Nice try though i give you a 7 for the effort of finding a suffixe thats better, not sure why but will throw one out there, pure good sounds good but sadlly it is no match for puncturing neither is backstabb ...

[Kaldaka]

Puncturing on the other hand is lethal quickly enough that it may kill something will high Will saves.

Agreed ... the high will save mobs usually have low CON. Beautiful weapon, but IMO if you want plat, don't sell it on the forums here. Like posted before, put a 1.9mil/2mil buyout on it in the AH. It will likely go for it, even if it takes a couple cycles, as there are quite a few people who don't come to these forums who will use the AH to buy stuff.

Another idea, put a LFM on the social page for the sale up anytime you are soloing loot runs or favor runs. If you are willing to take 1.4mil from the AH, I might suggest putting 1.5mil on the LFM.'

Good luck, and great pull

[Paladin20]

Thanks for the couple of PMs and the interest expressed, however, I have decided against trading the item, it will be well utilized in my upcoming Tempest build, I think I might never pull anything as good ever again lol. Anyways, my apologies if I was somewhat misleading.