Arcane Spell Failure and Seven-Fingered Gloves, a bug?

[Baryn]

When wearing the Seven-Fingered Gloves (which give -10% to ASF), it only affects one item with spell failure.

For example; if I wear a Heavy Mithral Shield that has 5% spell failure, and I wear a set of armor that has 5% spell failure, I still retain a 5% ASF chance.

Is this intended, or an overlooked calculation?

[Aspenor]

No enhancements or items which reduce ASF effect shield ASF. You must either use a shield with 0% asf naturally, or just deal with the 5%.

[Impaqt]

Bug report it.

[Aspenor]

Bug report it.

Its not a bug, Impaqt. The gloves should not affect shield ASF. Only armor asf.

[bobbryan2]

Its not a bug, Impaqt. The gloves should not affect shield ASF. Only armor asf.

And what are you basing that on? Other than, that's the way it's coded.

Seems to me the gloves should reduce shield asf too.

[Impaqt]

Its not a bug, Impaqt. The gloves should not affect shield ASF. Only armor asf.

Why?

It makes no sense to me that a Pair of gloves could reduce ASF from Armor but not from a Sheild....

[tihocan]

What does the description say in the first place?

[TreknaQudane]

Arcane Casting Dexterity: This ability reduces the arcane spell failure chance by -10%

And on this note; it does worth with shields, my Bard/Fighter has the gloves on and a shield with 5% ASF, I don't get that anymore since getting them.

[Graal]

7 fingered gloves reduce all forms of ASF. I ran a quick test and the gloves reduce ASF correctly when wearing both shield and armor.

There could still be a problem with your specific set of race, items, classes, feats, and enhancements so submit a bug with the necessary information and we'll check it out.

[Mad_Bombardier]

No enhancements or items which reduce ASF effect shield ASF.

Arcane Sigil Docents do. shhhhh...

[Baryn]

7 fingered gloves reduce all forms of ASF. I ran a quick test and the gloves reduce ASF correctly when wearing both shield and armor.

There could still be a problem with your specific set of race, items, classes, feats, and enhancements so submit a bug with the necessary information and we'll check it out.

Thanks very much for the quick response. Will double check my sets, and bug report if necessary.

EDIT: Checked my sets, did some testing, and submitted a bug report. When wearing +5 Padded Armor (5% failure), I have no ASF. When wearing a +5 Mithral Heavy Shield (5% failure). I have no ASF.

When wearing both of them, I have ASF. Unless there is a hidden extra +5% ASF for wearing armor you aren't proficient in, I'm not seeing why this happens. But it's reported, and hopefully it gets looked into.

[Soul-Shaker]

there is a bug, but its just display. My friend currently uses hvy mith ss, and a mith cs, with 1 drow asf enhancement. He gets the asf check on every cast but doesnt fail on even 1%.

[Aspenor]

I stand corrected, then. I don't have the gloves but I guess I assumed they worked the same as the enhancements do.