Originally Posted by
seldarin
Might want to keep in mind that not everyone has a bank full of +2 tomes lying around the shop to build new toons with, might want to think about that when posting builds.
the only tome really needed at L1 is the +2 int for more skill points. then again this build should have alot of skill points that do not need the int tome. note that with the assumption that 1750 favor points have been reach, +2 favor tome as well as raid tomes are possible
Secondly, i think that you are overlooking that this is a PnP derivative build, brought into DDO.
The one thing that is sorely lacking in DDO is theme builds, instead of cookie cutter, min/max dps/empowered/maximized blow the hell out of everything builds.
I may be lacking a little bit in memory from PnP days, and may not have a clue, being that i actually played a bladesinger character in PnP, BUT TOWER shields werent part of the arsenal. Therefore, your Fighter Tower Mastery enhancement doesnt fit in with that. If you played a bladesinger in PnP as you state, they didnt actually use shields at all.
if you read the my bladesinger template in the newbie thread, it is a 28 point theme build with 5 levels of wiz for self buffing. yeap bladesingers do not use shields at all but bear in mind that while you create a pnp build, you are playing it in a ddo environment. note that the OP quoted the +5 shield too. building a theme build is one thing, building a functional build is another but the shouldnt be exclusive
So when critiqueing a theme build, perhaps a bit more thought into factualisations about the particular class in question.
Power critical and critical accuracy are useful in helping boost your crits.
the only critique i made on the OP's build is the stat points, feats and enhancements. i have pointed out nothing else which is not factual. the build i posted was a sharing of different bladesinger builds not that the OP should follow my build. yes power critical and critical accuracy in confirming crit. however in ddo, their use fails miserably as there are items (ie seeker), more importantly, the amount of buffs readily availble is so much that the confirmation is almost always 100% (note this is at end game, enhancement and feat respect is available). the feat could probably be spent on ranged feats to make the range ability better
As i said this is a theme build from PnP, brought across to DDO and kept as close to PnP as possible, but a lot of the things you have added in, just dont fit that theme at all.
Additionally as much as you nitpicked the enhancements from Quans build, im curious looking at yours, how you proposed to lower your spell failure being you are utilising both armor and tower shields, yet no mention of any elven enhancements that reduce spell failure.