Originally Posted by
Wongar
I did some simple tests on rate of fire for a heavy repeater and a longbow. These were done on live 7 Oct 15 so are as current as can be.
The raw data is presented so everyone can draw their own conclusions. They make no attempt to represent DPS as that will depend heavily on other factors.
My opinion - this is the biggest reason bows are so far behind repeaters - you would need to get about 50% more damage per shot from the Longbow for it to catch up to the heavy repeater and I don't see how to do this.
I think these numbers also show that the proposed changes to manyshot will put bows even further behind in rate of fire - don't know if the RP boost will make up the difference or not. Notice with the proposed changes (1/2 Manyshot ROF) Bows will not even keep up with Repeaters when Manyshot is active.
Level 28
DC Destiny (Full BAB)
Feats: Blinding Speed, Rapid Reload, Rapid Shot, Longbow, Heavy Repeater
Weapons from Hammer & Chain
Method of test: Conjer a stack of 500 ammo with Flame Arrow Scroll
Run keyboard macro that holds the attack button for given time
For test with Manyshot, macro hits Manyshot then holds attack button for time
Subtract arrows left from 500 to get arrows shot
Shooting into air off ship
3 Runs of each setup were done
Results are xx/xx/xx where xx is one run
2 Minute duration was chosen to match Manyshot cool down
20 Sec duration was chosen to match Manyshot uptime
Double Shot 49%, Heavy Repeater: 2 Minutes
(No Double Shot Penalty)
421 / 406 / 395
Average: 3.39/sec
Double Shot 49%, NO manyshot Longbow: 2 Minutes
(No Double Shot Penalty)
216 / 217 / 221
Average: 1.82/sec
Double Shot 49%, WITH manyshot Longbow: 2 Minutes
(With Double Shot Penalty)
251 / 255 / 256
Average: 2.12/sec
Double Shot 49%, Heavy Repeater: 20 Seconds
71 / 74 / 68
Average: 3.55/sec
Double Shot 49%, NO manyshot Longbow: 20 Seconds
36 / 31 / 34
Average: 1.68/sec
Double Shot 49%, WITH manyshot Longbow: 20 Seconds
104 / 100 / 104
Average: 5.13/sec
Would be great if someone could do similar tests with a 10k/Manyshot build...