Ik'thanor's Signet Ring Divine Augmentation is Not Working

[LT218]

Divine augmentation on Ik'thanor's Signet Ring does not appear to be working. It appears this has been broken for over a year based on old posts on the DDO forums, Reddit, etc.

I tested it with both divine spells and SLAs. I get the exact same caster level in the combat logs with and without the ring equipped. Verified that I had no other sources of Divine Augmentation on gear.

I would assume the arcane augmentation portion of this is not working as well but I didn't test it.

[rabidfox]

Divine augmentation in general is mostly broken outside of healing spells (regardless of which item one is using to get it). This some testing I did on it a month or so ago and passed on to the devs.

https://i.imgur.com/2qepkod.png

[Enoach]

I would be curious to see from the "Does not work list" if the Arcane Augmentation works

I know that spells that are shared between Arcane and Divine caster classes have tended to follow the Arcane rules such as arcane spell failure (ASF) from Scrolls

There are spells on that list that fall in Arcane classes such as Bard.

[rabidfox]

I would be curious to see from the "Does not work list" if the Arcane Augmentation works

I know that spells that are shared between Arcane and Divine caster classes have tended to follow the Arcane rules such as arcane spell failure (ASF) from Scrolls

There are spells on that list that fall in Arcane classes such as Bard.

That was just the spells I had on my FvS, I'm sure there's a bunch more cleric/druid spells that also don't work. Last I checked, some worked with arcane augmentation and/or fire augmentation items. But really, all the stuff on the cleric/fvs/druid spell lists/SLAs should work with divine augmentation; a simpler solution might just to be ditch divine and arcane augmentation and replace it with a generic augmentation that just works on all spells/SLAs regardless of the spell's origin.

[Enoach]

That was just the spells I had on my FvS, I'm sure there's a bunch more cleric/druid spells that also don't work. Last I checked, some worked with arcane augmentation and/or fire augmentation items. But really, all the stuff on the cleric/fvs/druid spell lists/SLAs should work with divine augmentation; a simpler solution might just to be ditch divine and arcane augmentation and replace it with a generic augmentation that just works on all spells/SLAs regardless of the spell's origin.

I agree it should work. I wonder if the reason it doesn't work is because of how it is implemented and Arcane Flag is taking precedence, as in "Oh this is an arcane spell, ignore divine augmentation"

It gets dicey with multi-classing so I could see that approach being taken

[rabidfox]

I agree it should work. I wonder if the reason it doesn't work is because of how it is implemented and Arcane Flag is taking precedence, as in "Oh this is an arcane spell, ignore divine augmentation"

It gets dicey with multi-classing so I could see that approach being taken

A bunch of spells are missing the divine flag from what I could gather on the old thread about this.

[cru121]

My tests from few months ago


Works:
* Bless; Aid, Mass; Shield of Faith, Mass
* Cure spells, Heal
* Inflict spells
No effect:
* Nightshield, Death Ward, Protection from Elements, Resist Energy, Spawn Screen, Spell Resistance
* Soundburst, Holy Smite, Sunbeam, Searing Light, Nimbus of Light, Cometfall, Blade Barrier

[LT218]

Lynnabel, any chance of getting eyes on this any time soon? The Divine Augmentation effect is a pretty important thing to casters.