PDA

View Full Version : Shard Exchange



The10man
03-18-2013, 06:49 PM
/rant on

Ok this is the biggest scam you've pulled yet. Unless I completely misunderstand this is what is going on.

For the sake of easy math let's agree to pretend the following is correct: $=US Dollars, TP=Turbine Points, AS=Astral Shards, and 100TP=$1.00. (By this math with the deal 1AS~$0.06)

Player A loots awesome BTCoE item and decides to auction it on the Shard exchange. He buys the 500AS deal for 2795TP for $27.95. He lists the item for 1000AS at a cost of 5AS leaving him with 495AS.

Player B wants said item so he buys the 500AS deal twice for 5590TP or $55.90. He spends his 1000AS gets the item for $55.90.

The Exchange takes a 40% cut of the AS and Player A receives 600AS. So for his expenditure of $27.95 and his uber loot he got 1095AS worth about $65.70.

All in told Players A&B spent $83.85 and only $65.70 stayed with them in game. Essentially Turbine you have sold the 1500AS for $102 when you factor in the $18.15 in shards taken by the house.

Not only is this pay to win, but with the already EXPLODINGLY ASTRONOMICAL asking amounts for items it is ridiculous. /rant off

My thoughts:
1. There should be NO CUT for the house. You got your cut when the two players bought their shards. This is a blatant double charge.
2. If AS are going to be the currency then there needs to be a way to loot/trade for them in game more readily. VIPS pay for playing already as do premium players to a different extent. (some more, some less)

Thoughts?

Silken-Akira
03-19-2013, 06:45 AM
+1 on the detail . and my thought is that you are right it is indeed a scam. but then again that is the hidden function of a lot of companies to scam more money from people then it is really worth. so no surprise there for me. Just glad it is so obvious. As for people with kids and no IT knowledge at all. I hope that for them they don't see a sudden big bill coming in. Which sooner or later turbine would a kind of lawsuit against them maybe, As the daily dice being a kind of gambling method and indeed not enough parent control now they have introduced this astral shard system.
I hope for our and Turbine sake they realize they went overboard with this one and correct it.

Impaqt
03-19-2013, 07:04 AM
people are testing the waters right now. we're gonna see some stupid prices. doesnt mean people are actually spending that.

You dont have to buy 500 shards to list an item. not sure where that came from.

yes, the Turbine cut is way too high.

VIP's should get some free AS each month in addition to TP's. Or lower cut on auctions perhaps?

Qhualor
03-19-2013, 07:18 AM
VIPs getting some AS along with TP makes sense, but you cant double dip them that way.

Impaqt
03-19-2013, 07:22 AM
VIPs getting some AS along with TP makes sense, but you cant double dip them that way.

why? Pretty sure turbine can give whatever they want to whomever they want.

The10man
03-19-2013, 08:39 AM
You are correct sir in that you do not have to buy 500AS to list an item. I simply took the deal that popped up first when I opened the store and used it for both players as an example. To simplify the math if you will.