largest guild?

[noscarrell]

curiosity killed the barb,but i must kno,,who is the largest ACTIVE guild?(any server)
also who is the oldest active guild?(any server)

keep this clean yall,, this barb is lookin for facts not fictions. so back your claims up with screenies or dont claim it.

[mudfud]

The largest and most active guild is the one with the invisible name.
We are on all servers, accept all types of players.

[irivan]

you should ask at the different server forums for largest guild count and then compare notes, come back and tell us.

[geoffhanna]

We only allow halflings... does this put us in the running for smallest guild?

[Lost_Leader]

We only allow halflings... does this put us in the running for smallest guild?

If so, wouldn't that make the Forged Legion one of the largest?

[Nadalis]

Shoot...
Forged Legions: they get to be the largest cuz they warforged.

I was hoping to help my guild out to be the largest. Shoot, when my wife is tryin to talk me up real sweet, she says my pant size and IQ are almost the same, and that makes me purdy smart. Shoot my size don't mean nuthin? I gunna start rolling them warforged then.

[Ithrani]

Shoot...
Forged Legions: they get to be the largest cuz they warforged.

I was hoping to help my guild out to be the largest. Shoot, when my wife is tryin to talk me up real sweet, she says my pant size and IQ are almost the same, and that makes me purdy smart. Shoot my size don't mean nuthin? I gunna start rolling them warforged then.

Being a large guild doesn't mean jack, nor does being the largest on the server. What determines largest, is it number of overall members or number of active players? You can easily see how many character members are in a guild in myddo by looking up the guild, but that hardly matters. I personally never remove people from my guild no matter how long they are inactive, causing our numbers to be high over 500 characters, despite there only being maybe 20-30 active members atm. Being large in active members means more drama, more newbs, lower IQ.

Less is more in this case, just recruiting to fill numbers means implosion of a guild. You are better off with having 15 good active members then 100 active dolts.

[Lost_Leader]

Being a large guild doesn't mean jack, nor does being the largest on the server. What determines largest, is it number of overall members or number of active players? You can easily see how many character members are in a guild in myddo by looking up the guild, but that hardly matters. I personally never remove people from my guild no matter how long they are inactive, causing our numbers to be high over 500 characters, despite there only being maybe 20-30 active members atm. Being large in active members means more drama, more newbs, lower IQ.

Less is more in this case, just recruiting to fill numbers means implosion of a guild. You are better off with having 15 good active members then 100 active dolts.

I think you meant to quote the OP there, not the guy talking about the "largest" being an all wf guild or the "smallest" being all halfling... or were you looking at his pants?

Though, in all seriousness, I agree with you when in response to the OP. To the OP, unlike in some other scenarios, when it comes to guilds, size does not equal quality. Nor is it even indicative of activity. Though, you weren't asking about quality, just size, for some weird social behavior study or some-such, perhaps.

[Ithrani]

I think you meant to quote the OP there, not the guy talking about the "largest" being an all wf guild or the "smallest" being all halfling... or were you looking at his pants?

Though, in all seriousness, I agree with you when in response to the OP. To the OP, unlike in some other scenarios, when it comes to guilds, size does not equal quality. Nor is it even indicative of activity. Though, you weren't asking about quality, just size, for some weird social behavior study or some-such, perhaps.

No I know Mani, I don't think he considers large guilds good, but Nada said he was trying to help his guild be the largest, which I when I replied to him. But either way, we agree that large guilds are not a great thing, quality over quantity is far better.

[Zzevel]

Technically wouldnt it be the guild with the most reincarnated toons? they are a bit larger is stature..

[Nadalis]

Clearly my ill-fated attempt at humor didn't go over so well.

The topic was derailed when we poked fun at the idea that the OP might be implying physical stature of the characters when me meant "largest ACTIVE guild." I tired to take it one step further using self-depricating humor (my large wasit size combine with my low IQ) to point out that the OP might have been looking for the guild with the largest players, in terms of waist size and physical stature.

I think we can all agree that guild quality is a much different conversation. I don't think anyone is daft enough to think guild population numbers alone determine guild quality. I apologize if my sad attempt at humor confused my intentions.


Unfortunately for the OP, the only parameters were a clean discussion and ACTIVE members (No one could brag about which guild was the most well-endowed. Thank the maker the discussion wasn't brought down to that level). More restrictions might drive the conversation toward an answer like a definition of active, active players or active characters, etc. I fear even with better parameters, the curiosity will remain as such, as there might be too much work entailed to look up all the active characters or players for guilds.


curiosity killed the barb, but I must know who is the largest ACTIVE guild?(any server)
also who is the oldest active guild?(any server)

keep this clean yall, this barb is lookin for facts not fictions. so back your claims up with screenies or dont claim it.

To the OP: Good luck finding an answer, I hope your curiosity is satiated. I am wondering if the guild housing system will somehow bring enlightenment to your answer. I wonder if we will see quality guilds esstablish good blimps, while large we will see some guilds tryng to squeeze all of their peeps into a flying mobile home.

[Lorien_the_First_One]

You can easily see how many character members are in a guild in myddo by looking up the guild,.

Actually that's a bit buggy, it overreports members.

[Kalari]

Dunno about the largest but we drink the most liquor so does that count for anything? Oh and bra cup size I think our guild has it hands down (even though theres only 6 active females currently :p)

[Nadalis]

Oh and bra cup size

Ah! AH! Ah! Kalari, you know the rules, OP said screenies or it doesn't count! JK! JK! I kid, I kid, you open the door, and I couldn't help it.



Oh and bra cup size I think our guild has it hands down (even though theres only 6 active females currently :p)

He wouldn't want the six of you to go it alone, he leads in all ways. Creeg does a pretty good dwarven female impression when he goes drag, and even if some of it might be stuffing, he still gets a good bra cup size.

[williamsond]

The Unrepentant is (--------------------THIS------------------) big we would have been bigger but it was cold and we're hung over from all the awsome sauce.

[Temko]

numbers only matter in PvP games (Darkfall, EvE, etc...) here, all that matters is: can your guild organsize a daily elite raid for a full group (or more) during primetime?

Yes/no?