Crafting: Earthgrab: Help

[MAP1974]

Recently upgraded my all earth bracers to tier 3, fully expecting to get 'moderate good guard' (as per Wiki). My bracers however say earthgrab, and after a quick test in the desert they do indeed have earthgrab.

Is Wiki unreliable?

[Aranticus]

good guard is from positive line

it can be

a) you read wrongly
b) wiki is wrong

and if wiki is wrong
a) its a geniune mistake
b) someone intentionally f-ed it up

ps: i always use this
http://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=pLaIqDL_IzJRx5CcCEpCaYg&gid=6

[Borror0]

Recently upgraded my all earth bracers to tier 3, fully expecting to get 'moderate good guard' (as per Wiki). My bracers however say earthgrab, and after a quick test in the desert they do indeed have earthgrab.

Is Wiki unreliable?

Actually, that means they fixed it and didn't tell us about it.

Before, there was no description and by testing, Moderate Good Guard was what was on it. Sorry you had to pay for it.

[Borror0]

good guard is from positive line

False, positive line is Greater Disruption Guard.


ps: i always use this
http://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=pLaIqDL_IzJRx5CcCEpCaYg&gid=6

Even your link says it's a guard effect. ;) Althought, it says Evil Guard.

As for someone messing up the wiki, it's really rare. I check the recent changes Very often. Like 4+ times a day.

EDIT: So does Cambo, here (http://forums.ddo.com/showpost.php?p=1519598&postcount=4).

"Earth Bonus on item is not shown, possbile bug, but good guard damage is occuring in combat log."

[MAP1974]

Thanks for the prompt responses.

I note the link Aranticus sent mentions 'moderate good guard'; perhaps something to be careful of?

For what it is worth, I will take the 'earthgrab' instead of the 'moderate good guard' with a big smile on my face (1d8 being pretty useless imo).

[Aranticus]

False, positive line is Greater Disruption Guard.

good guard is in the positive line but it is not the posx3 effect, which is why i asked if the OP got it mixed up


Even your link says it's a guard effect. ;) Althought, it says Evil Guard.

As for someone messing up the wiki, it's really rare. I check the recent changes Very often. Like 4+ times a day.

lol u have TOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much time.... then again.... me too :eek:

[Borror0]

lol u have TOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much time.... then again.... me too :eek:

I'm in a Shroud run, 11 members with one cleric... and entering part 2... one guildy has gone missing. We suspect falling asleep at the keyboard.

[tihocan]

Awesome, thanks for sharing this, I had still that one marked as unknown on my planner, updating it now :)